If you don't like "Railroading", think instead about tour guides, or theme park rides.
Is this a form of manipulation?
Definitely. So it should be done by consent. “Guys, I’m going to be using all sorts of subtle techniques to help guide the story, a bit like a director, but only on occasions when I think a specific direction will be more entertaining to all of us. If you trust me to do what's best for our game - which is what most players trust their GMs to do anyway, and see every other episode we did on details of why and how - then everything will be great.”
The point of this (5:17)
Encouraging players to make a specific choice, without imposing the choice on them.
Brute force railroading (6:40)
AKA: Fast Forward, cutscene, Walkthrough or Statement
Setting the scene.
Negative reinforcement (9:30)
Positive reinforcement (10:45)
Consultation / delay (11:25)
Consult the rule books. Try to remember/pretend to try and remember a specific detail.
Schrodinger's Dungeon (14:30)
Extra Credit, the illusion of choice
RailRolling (18:45)
Guiding questions (20:50)
Priming
Specificity, giving extra details (26:10)
The law of conservation of details
The player’s perspective (28:25)
Don’t be a cynic.
Taking the load off (33:05)
Uri: “Have I added to the sum of goodness in the world”?
Eran: Savage World's 50 Fathoms: arrived at a city, didn’t want to spend 3 weeks, so let’s take the tension off and let them feel relieved.
-----
Email us at
[email protected] with questions, topic suggestions, and comments on this episode. We have a Patreon page, in case you'd like to support us in a monetary fashion. Our Facebook group. Most links to DriveThruRPG are affiliate, which means we get a bit of money if you buy through them, with no added cost to you.