Amber and Scott tackle Supergirl, diving into the messy, grief-stricken reality of Kara Zor-El’s life as a displaced alien struggling to find purpose on Earth. The hosts trade barbs over the movie’s questionable tonal shifts, specifically questioning the necessity of gratuitous profanity and the dark, unsettling subplots involving child abduction in what is otherwise a superhero spectacle. Their back-and-forth captures the frustration of watching a potentially family-friendly action film veer into unnecessarily edgy territory, all while Scott tries to reconcile his confusion over the film's specific Kryptonian lore.

Some What Would You Dos from the episode:

• If you were Ruthie, would you seek revenge on the man who destroyed your family, or would you let it go after seeing the carnage he leaves behind?
• If you were in Kara’s position—possessing god-like powers under a yellow sun but wanting to escape the burden of responsibility—would you choose to live a quiet, indifferent life under a red sun?
• If you were an innocent bystander unknowingly caught in the crosshairs of a super-powered conflict, how would you handle being asked to transport a dangerous, alien fugitive?
• If you had the chance to deliver the final blow to the villain who ruined your life, would you take the shot, or would you heed the advice of a hero trying to save your moral soul?

The conversation hits a peak of hilarity when the hosts debate the finer points of vengeance, with Scott insisting that he wouldn't just settle for a defeat—he would want the villain's head on a spike as a souvenir. Amber remains skeptical of his dark creative vision, leaving the episode on a ridiculous note about how many heads a bad guy actually has.