<p>Susan not only killed her children she then was living the good life while in prison.</p>
<p>After receiving her life sentence, Smith was booked into the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Institution in Columbia. In August 2000, Susan told administrators at the prison she had sex four times on prison grounds with 50-year-old prison guard Houston Cagle. Cagle later pleaded guilty for these charges and served three months in prison. A year later Susan did it again and prison captain, Alfred Rowe, confessed to having sex with Smith and was sentenced to five years' probation.</p>

Susan not only killed her children she then was living the good life while in prison. After receiving her life sentence, Smith was booked into the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Institution in Columbia. In August 2000, Susan told administrators at the prison she had sex four times on prison grounds with 50-year-old prison guard Houston Cagle. Cagle later pleaded guilty for these charges and served three months in prison. A year later Susan did it again and prison captain, Alfred Rowe, confessed to having sex with Smith and was sentenced to five years' probation.

<p>Susan not only killed her children she then was living the good life while in prison.</p>
<p>After receiving her life sentence, Smith was booked into the Camille Griffin Graham Correctional Institution in Columbia.&nbsp;In August 2000, Susan told administrators at the prison she had sex four times on prison grounds with 50-year-old prison guard Houston Cagle. Cagle later pleaded guilty for these charges and served three months in prison. A year later Susan did it again and prison captain, Alfred Rowe, confessed to having sex with Smith and was sentenced to five years' probation.</p>

Susan Smith the 2nd Episode

<div>Early on Wednesday.</div>
<div></div>
<div>That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams.</div>
<div></div>
<div>Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open.</div>
<div></div>
<div>But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark.</div>
<div></div>
<div>On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl.</div>
<div></div>
<div>Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.</div>

Religion & Spirituality

True Crime

Spirituality

History

Early on Wednesday. That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams. Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open. But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark. On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl. Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.

Early on Wednesday.

That’s when the stories nobody wants to tell start to unravel. When the headlines have gone quiet, but the evidence still screams.

Every week, two investigative journalists dig past the official reports and tear into the cases that never found closure. Unsolved murders, vanishing cults, the fractured psychology behind true crime—if there’s a file stamped “inconclusive,” we’re the ones prying it open.

But we don’t stop at crime scenes and courtrooms. We follow the trail into conspiracies, cryptids, and the paranormal—anywhere the facts twist into something darker. We gather what’s buried, piece together what’s missing, and hold up the uncomfortable truths that most would rather leave in the dark.

On Early on Wednesday, you’ll find the psychological patterns behind the horror, the hidden details history tried to erase, and the connections that make your skin crawl.

Because every mystery leaves a paper trail. And we intend to follow it—wherever it leads.

Share Susan Smith the 2nd Episode

Sign up to save your podcasts

Susan Smith the 2nd Episode

Susan Smith the 2nd Episode

More shows like Early On Wednesday

William Ramsey Investigates

Codega's Codex of Curiosities

The Targeted Individual Podcast

The Hometown Horrors Podcast