He may be the apple of Stifler's Mom's eye, but EDDIE KAYE THOMAS is much more than "American Pie's" Paul Finch. A stage veteran (since he was 7 years old!), Eddie chatted with us about working with Natalie Portman on Broadway as a teen, starring alongside Katie Holmes and Sarah Cooper in "The Wanderers" in NYC (this amazing show ends on April 2nd, so go see it if you can!), and - of course - whether a new "American Pie" sequel is in the works (and what HE thinks it should be about!)

Subscribe to "90's to Now" for FREE at youtube /@90stoNow and be the first to watch/hear our latest chats with your favorites from the 90's and beyond! Plus, join us at our Facebook Group for giveaways, episode previews and special events at https://bit.ly/3if1DMA