Send us a text

This episode is wild! Herbert Baumeister was a man who was born into a conservative family and fell in love with a conservative woman. Or so that's how it looked on the outside. Herbert was hiding sexual sadism, a urine fetish and his homosexuality from everyone around him... oh yeah... and he was also hiding close to 30 some bodies in the woods around his home at Fox Hollow Farm in Indiana. 

When the number of missing person cases in the gay community became too big to ignore, the police started actually looking for a killer. It was the 90's, so the cops didn't really care about the LGBT community. In fact, the conservative state of Indiana brushed most of them under the rug until the families of the victims' voices grew louder. 

Join us as we talk about Herbert Baumeister's early life, his crimes, the crimes he's linked to and the terror he causes on fox hollow farm to this day. In this two-part episode we have a little true crime and a little paranormal for your ear holes. 

References:
https://youtu.be/wpKh8Oqy9Pc?si=PORPAOvd1yFf0-LS

https://indyencyclopedia.org/herbert-baumeister/#:~:text=In%201974%2C%20Baumeister%20found%20work,another%20man%20dressed%20in%20drag.

the horrors of fox hollow farm: unraveling the history and hauntings of a serial killers home by Richard Estep and Robert Graves

https://abcnews.go.com/Primetime/story?id=132035&page=1#:~:text=But%20the%20Lutzes%20sat%20down,of%20the%20night....
https://www.investigationdiscovery.com/crimefeed/murder/amityville-horror-inside-the-defeo-family-s-brutal-murders
 
The haunting of fox hollow farm documentary on tubi 2004 

Support the show

If you want to support the show please go to our host site and subscribe to get access to bonus episodes and content. rogueandwicked.buzzsprout.com or you can leave us a 5 star review on any and all platforms.

Please check out our other social media sites for upcoming episodes and shorts. You can find us on TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, X, Patreon and YouTube @rogueandwicked (don't forget to like, share and subscribe)

CHECK OUT OUR SUBSTACK FOR UPDATES ON CASES WE COVERED, Current true crime news and Live streams @rogueandwicked

Script's, Editing, Social Media and the Creator of the show: Tiffany
Co-host and author of the book series "sage": Wendy
Music by Bo Todd