In this emotionally charged episode of The Guilty Files: Revisited, Brian and Dani take on one of the most haunting and high-profile true crime cases of the last decade: the disappearance and murder of Gabby Petito.From the outside, Gabby’s story looked like a dream life shared through van-life vlogs and Instagram-perfect snapshots. But as Brian and Dani dig deeper into the case file, they expose the far more disturbing truth beneath the curated lens of social media.

What begins as a chronological walk-through of Gabby and Brian Laundrie’s cross-country trip quickly turns into a sobering examination of the red flags, missed intervention opportunities, and systemic failures that paved the way to tragedy.Brian brings his procedural lens to the infamous Moab police stop, offering a critical look at how law enforcement misread clear signs of domestic violence—and how that single decision might have changed the entire outcome.

 Dani, on the other hand, peels back the psychological layers of coercive control and emotional abuse, showing just how often the warning signs are hidden in plain sight, if only we’re willing to look.Together, they reflect on the media frenzy that surrounded the case—how internet sleuths, true crime TikTok, and mainstream outlets turned Gabby’s disappearance into a national obsession. They ask hard questions about who gets attention when they go missing, and who’s left in silence.

This episode isn’t just about Gabby’s death—it’s about the systems that failed her, the warning signs society ignores, and the echo chamber that sometimes does more harm than good. It’s about what it means to truly see someone who’s crying out for help in all the ways she can, without ever raising her voice.For Brian, it’s a case that exemplifies everything wrong with how we handle domestic calls in the field. For Dani, it’s a devastating reminder of how normalized emotional abuse has become, and how easily it gets dismissed until it’s too late. Listeners are reminded that this episode contains sensitive content, including discussion of domestic violence and intimate partner homicide.

Stay until the end for an exclusive teaser of the Behind the Badge bonus segment on Patreon, where Brian and Dani share their own personal stories of domestic calls that still haunt them to this day.