In this episode of A Reasonable Response, Robert Bosley refutes the claims of self-identified Christian progressive James Talarico and argues that his theology and proposed policies cannot meaningfully be called Christian.

Bosley contends that the central issue is not personal identification or academic affiliation, but authority. When the sufficiency of Scripture is rejected and replaced with personal tradition, cultural ideology, or political theory, the foundation of historic Protestant Christianity is abandoned. A system built on shifting human ideas cannot provide the sure footing that only God’s Word supplies.

This episode calls listeners to examine modern progressive theology in light of Scripture’s authority and to remember that Christian identity is defined not by label, but by submission to the revealed Word of God.