This week, The Neighbors are making the ultimate summer decision—ranking ice cream flavors, but only the fun ones. We’ve built a full-on ice cream flavor bracket with over a dozen contenders battling it out, including matcha, coffee chip, Cookie Monster, raspberry chip, sherbet, and more. Expect passionate debates, surprise upsets, and way too many cravings by the end of this episode.

Grab a cone and play along—you might be shocked by which flavor takes the crown.