What’s scarier than getting older? Realizing the party was never meant for you.

This week on the Scary Spirits Podcast, we celebrate Karen’s birthday the only way that feels right—by diving headfirst into the bizarre, chaotic, and wildly unpredictable 2004 cult horror film The Birthday, starring Corey Feldman. What begins as a simple birthday party spirals into something far stranger, funnier, and more uncomfortable than expected… and that’s exactly how we like it.

Join hosts Karen and Greg as they unpack this under‑seen cult classic, exploring its surreal tone, off‑kilter performances, and the creeping sense that something is very wrong beneath the frosting and balloons. It’s horror, it’s comedy, it’s confusion—and it’s a reminder that birthdays can be terrifying when the rules of reality quietly slip away.

To toast the occasion, the hosts sip on a specially crafted “Happy Birthday Martini,” because nothing pairs with existential dread quite like a well‑mixed cocktail.

If you love cult horror films, strange party movies, Corey Feldman performances, and a horror podcast that laughs nervously while staring into the abyss, this episode of Scary Spirits is your invitation.

Just remember… not everyone leaves the party the same way they arrived.

Happy Birthday Martini

• 1 tsp white sugar
• 1 tsp fresh lemon juice
• 1 oz pomegranate juice
• 2 oz vodka
• 3 ice cubes
• 2 strips lemon peel

Instructions:

Source: allrecipes.com

A Brief Synopsis: A man attends a bizarre birthday party at a fancy but sinister hotel.

Some of the topics discussed and highlights of this episode include:

Our rating of the film:

This movie was OK. It took us 3 cocktails to get through it.

Take our online survey!

We want to know more about you! Please take our survey. All questions are optional and you can remain completely anonymous if you prefer. Tell us what you like or would like to hear more of!

All music on the Scary Spirits Podcast is provided by the band “Verse 13”. Please check them out. You can listen to all their music on their Bandcamp page.

Shoot us an email at [email protected]

As an Amazon Associate, we may earn a small percentage of qualifying purchases through our links.