The Cabbage Coins Podcast

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins Podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz welcomes back coin expert Larry Shepherd to discuss the intricacies of collecting Peace Dollars. The conversation covers various aspects of the Peace Dollar series, including its collectability, market trends compared to Morgan Dollars, grading challenges, historical context, and investment insights on key dates like the 1924-S and 1925-S. Larry shares his expertise on the beauty and rarity of these coins, emphasizing the importance of quality and grading in the market. The discussion also touches on the growing trend of artificially toned coins and the need for collectors to be cautious in their purchases.

Guest info:
Larry Shepherd
President/Owner – SIMCO Numismatics
Website - https://simplythefinestcommems.com/
Email - [email protected]

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

“Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.”

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

Chapters:
00:00 Introduction to Peace Dollars and Guest Reintroduction
02:45 Collecting Peace Dollars: Approaches and Budgeting
05:55 Market Trends: Comparing Peace and Morgan Dollars
09:01 Grading Challenges: Overgrading in the Market
12:02 Historical Context: The Design and Production of Peace Dollars
17:56 Key Dates: The Significance of the 1924-S
24:01 Investment Insights: The 1925-S and Market Value
30:06 Conclusion: Final Thoughts on Peace Dollar Collecting
30:51 Grading and Valuation of Coins
35:11 Analyzing Coin Quality: Obverse vs. Reverse
38:01 The 1926 S: A Collector's Gem
39:49 Market Trends and Collector Insights
42:28 Understanding Key Dates in the Peace Dollar Series
49:45 The Quintessential Type Coin: 1935 S
51:23 The Controversy of Color in Peace Dollars

Eric Lindholm of Sublime Cents returns to the Cabbage Coins Podcast to cover early Lincoln cents. He and Tony Gryckiewicz go through example coins: Philadelphia vs. San Francisco strikes, planchet quality, color grades, rare key dates, and natural vs. problem toning. They close with a few rapid-fire questions.

Key topics and takeaways
Why Lincoln cents are popular (2:20): They're accessible, and they're an icon of American coinage. Eric says both cents series are strong in the market right now.
San Francisco alloy problems (4:23): Early S-mint coins often have improperly mixed bronze. That leaves streaks and "wood grain" patterns on the surface, as on the 1909-S VDB.
Spotting cleaned coins (9:14): Look for fine lines in the fields and an excess of whiteness when you tilt the coin. Tony also explains the range from chemical to mechanical cleaning.
Philadelphia coins should be near-perfect (13:05): Look for sharp rims, strong detail and good luster. Collect higher grades of these, since they're more plentiful.
S-mints are weaker (14:00, 22:08): Expect weak strikes and uneven planchets on the 1917-S. Even the best examples won't match Philadelphia coins.
Red vs. brown (16:02): Some mellowing of the red is normal on early S-mint coins, so grading is more lenient there. Eric shares a story about buying a 1921-S at the Long Beach show, and how the Gray Sheet price was a poor guide for nice early red coins (16:28).
Dealer risk and offers (19:25): Tony and Eric discuss who should name the price and the risk dealers take on when they buy.
Strike tip (24:02): Check whether the "O" in "ONE" is fully struck.
Orange peel texture and luster (26:00, 37:10): A bumpy "orange peel" surface and a band of luster around the face are good signs. Coins that look flat usually aren't.
Grading focus (27:00): Graders seem to care more about clean fields than hits on the portrait. Eric adds that a clean jacket is something to look for (52:07).
1926-S key date (29:01): An MS65+ red is listed at about $125,000, and a 66 brown could be worth around $200,000 in a red holder. Eric suggests a nice MS65 brown (about $3,000) as a budget alternative to chasing one color (35:21).
Toning (36:05–54:40): Eric covers raspberry, honeycomb/yellow, blue and rainbow toning, with premiums ranging from none to several times a coin's value. Natural toning tends to be non-uniform with mixed colors. Monochrome, electric colors call for caution. A rainbow-toned cent he sold for $750 on eBay shows how big the premiums can get.
Conservation caution (40:17): One coin had a light film lifted with a Q-tip. Eric and Tony both warn against experimenting on valuable coins.

Rapid-fire questions (55:33)
Favorite non-cent series: Barber quarters.
Favorite shows: the FUN show, Central States (Schaumburg, IL), and Long Beach.
Favorite book: Rick Snow's book on Indian cents and Flying Eagles.

Where to find Eric:
sublimecents.com
IG: @sublime_cents

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

“Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.”

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins Podcast, hosts Tony Gryckiewicz and Noah Lehmann-Haupt discuss their top ten losses in coin dealing. They share personal stories behind each loss, emphasizing the lessons learned and the importance of understanding market demand, grading, and the stories behind coins. The conversation highlights the challenges of pricing, the significance of collector preferences, and the dynamics of the numismatic market. The discussion highlights the need for caution, patience, and informed decision-making in the world of coin collecting and trading. They share personal anecdotes about scams, market fluctuations, and the challenges of the upgrade game, providing valuable insights for both collectors and dealers.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Coin Losses
03:11 The Story Behind the 1884 Proof Set
05:55 Understanding Market Demand for Proof Sets
09:09 The 1991 CC Ten Dollar Coin
11:46 The 1957 Half Dime Experience
14:56 The 59-S Coin and Market Dynamics
18:13 The 1951 Franklin Coin Trap
21:02 The 1872 CC Ten Dollar Coin
37:46 Lessons from a $700 Loss
38:41 Understanding CC Gold Coins
39:48 The Risks of Trading Coins
44:35 The Perils of Coin Restoration
49:56 Learning from Counterfeit Coins
57:53 The Challenge of High-Value Coins
63:04 Navigating Plus Grade Coins
68:05 The Allure and Risks of CAC Coins
70:12 The Risks of Buying Coins on Social Media
78:46 Lessons from Expensive Coin Purchases
82:54 The Upgrade Game: Risks and Rewards
87:22 Scams and Trust in the Coin Community
91:50 Market Fluctuations and Their Impact on Coin Values

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Where to find Noah and Rarity7:
https://www.rarity7.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @rarity7coins

“Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.”

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this conversation, Tony Gryckiewicz, Mike Nottelmann, Ben TheCoinGeek and David Tine discuss current trends in the coin market, particularly focusing on the US Mint's recent releases. The discussion covers the state of coin shops, the excitement and challenges surrounding bullion sales, and a detailed critique of various mint products, including innovative designs and disappointing releases. The hosts share their ratings and opinions on several coins, providing insights into the collector's perspective and market dynamics. They explore specific coins, including the Breast Cancer Awareness coin, Enhanced Reverse Proof coins, and the recent DC Comics series, highlighting the balance between aesthetics, rarity, and market trends. The redesign of classic coins, such as the dime, is also examined, with insights into how these changes resonate with collectors. In this conversation, the participants discuss various aspects of coin design, focusing on recent US Mint products. They explore the artistic interpretations of coin designs, the significance of commemorative coins, and the aesthetics of modern coins. The discussion also touches on the concept of retreads in coin design, the innovation of curved coins, and the mixed reception of the Best of the Mint series. Finally, they provide recommendations for collectors on which coins to consider for their collections.

00:00 - Show Introduction and Guest Lineup
01:05 - Coin Shop Updates and Bullion Market Trends
03:36 - Introducing the US Mint Product Discussion
04:45 - Liberty Bell Gold Coin Review and Ratings
09:46 - 2014 Baseball Hall of Fame Concave Coin
13:53 - 2017 Enhanced Uncirculated Set Critique
18:12 - 2021 High-Relief Gold Eagle Assessment
23:00 - US Mint Pricing Strategies and Market Impact
25:34 - V75 WWII Anniversary Coin and Privy-Mark Gold Eagle
28:09 - Half-Ounce Gold Medal and Rare Gold Eagle Variants
30:38 - 2018 Breast Cancer Rose-Gold Coin Review
35:15 - 2019 S-Enhanced Reverse Proof Silver Eagle
38:48 - DC Superhero Coin Design Critique
44:08 - Design Critiques: 2001 Buffalo Nickel and 2026 Pilgrim Quarter
49:32 - Negative Review of the 2001 Buffalo Coin
50:55 - V75 Gold Eagle Rarity and Market Performance
53:57 - Final Thoughts on the 2026 Pilgrim Quarter Series
55:31 - Second Curved Coin: The Astronaut Design
57:13 - More on the Astronaut Curved Coin
1:00:59 - Best of the Mint: The 1804 Dollar Debate
1:02:26 - More on the Best of the Mint 1804 Dollar
1:05:40 - Recommendation: 2008 Quarter-Ounce Gold Buffalo
1:07:14 - 2007 Proof Platinum Frosted Freedom Mint Error
1:08:08 - Collector Advice and Underappreciated Mint Coins
1:11:27 - Closing Remarks and Thanks
1:45:08 - Outro

Ben TheCoinGeek
Host of “TheCoinGeek” YouTube Channel
https://www.oldpueblocoin.com/
email: [email protected]
 
Mike Nottelmann
Co-Host of “The Coin Show Podcast” on YouTube
https://coinshowradio.com/
email: [email protected]
 
David Tine
Owner of Eagle Coin & Precious Metals – Eagle, ID
https://eaglecoinshop.com/
email: [email protected]

Tony Gryckiewicz
Owner of Cabbage Coins
https://cabbagecoins.com/
email: [email protected]

“Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.”

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins Podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz welcomes back Doug Winter to discuss affordable pre-1933 gold coins. They explore various price ranges, focusing on coins that collectors can acquire without breaking the bank. Doug shares insights on specific coins, their historical significance, and the current market trends, including the impact of the Fairmont Collection on coin values. The conversation emphasizes the accessibility of gold coins for collectors of all budgets and the importance of research in the numismatic community. They also discuss the appeal of type one $20s, the impact of shipwrecks on coin populations, and the nuances of Carson City $20s. The conversation also touches on the importance of originality in coins, the subjective nature of grading, and the significance of classic head gold coins. Additionally, they share insights on favorite coin series and recommend top coin shows for collectors.

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Doug Winter
Owner - Doug Winter Numismatics
IG: @raregoldcoins
Website: raregoldcoins.com
Website: doubleeaglebook.com
Email: [email protected]

“Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.”

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz and guest Ken Conway delve into the fascinating world of vintage silver ingots, particularly focusing on government ingots from the San Francisco and Philadelphia mints. Ken shares his journey into collecting, the evolution of the market for these ingots, and the various factors that contribute to their value. The conversation also touches on the purpose behind the production of these ingots, the role of different mints, and strategies for collectors to organize and value their collections. Tony and Ken explore the evolution of ingot sizes, the rarity of certain bars, and the unique characteristics that make vintage ingots valuable. The discussion also touches on the importance of information in the collecting community and the stories behind personalized bars. Ken shares insights from his extensive experience in the field, providing listeners with a deeper understanding of the numismatic landscape.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Vintage Silver Ingots
01:27 Ken Conway's Journey into Collecting
03:53 The Evolution of Government Ingots
05:43 Understanding the Value of Ingots
11:48 The Purpose and Production of Ingots
15:29 Philadelphia Mint's Role in Ingots
21:08 Collecting Strategies and Organization
30:10 Complete Type Set of Ingots
32:48 Understanding Silver Ingot Types
35:09 The Evolution of Ingot Sizes
37:04 Collector Insights on Rare Bars
39:28 Exploring the Rarity of Denver Mint Ingots
42:16 Unique Characteristics of Vintage Ingots
44:56 The Significance of the 'Cube' Ingot
46:01 The Role of Information in Collecting
48:31 The Mystery of New York Assay Office Bars
50:47 Grease Bars and Their Historical Context
53:22 Personalized Bars and Their Stories
56:58 Reflections on Collecting and Future Plans

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Where to see Ken's collection and research:
https://www.silveringots.com/

Video editing and post-production by Manuel — specializing in podcast, YouTube, and digital content editing.

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins podcast, Tony Gryckiewicz and Russell Augustin delve into the recent auction results of the Bostonian collection at Stacks Bowers. They discuss the performance of various coins, the significance of the Yankee Blade publication, and the impact of gold prices on collectible values. The conversation also touches on market trends, the rise of colonial coins, and the implications of recent discoveries in the numismatic field. They focus on modern patterns, gold commemoratives, and investment strategies in numismatics. They discuss the performance of specific coins from the Bostonian collection, the impact of CAC on coin value, and the importance of understanding market dynamics for successful investing in coins.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Cabbage Coins Podcast
01:26 Exploring the Yankee Blade Publication
03:48 Post-Auction Analysis of the Bostonian Collection
06:10 Significant Gains in Coin Values
10:05 The Impact of Gold Prices on Collectibles
13:06 Market Trends in Early Dollar Coins
16:30 The Value of Historical Coins
21:05 The Rise of Colonial Coins
27:42 Understanding Market Dynamics and Hoards
35:53 Future Implications of Recent Discoveries
38:36 Understanding Modern Coin Patterns
47:42 The Performance of Gold Commemoratives
51:29 Investment Strategies in Numismatics
61:48 The Role of CAC in Coin Collecting

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Russell Augustin
Senior Numismatist - RARCOA
www.AUCM.com
Email: [email protected]

Upcoming Show Schedule:
https://cabbagecoins.com/coinshows/

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz interviews author William Dokas about his extensive book, 'The History of American Money and Physical Specie in North America.' They discuss William's journey into coin collecting, the motivations behind his writing, the challenges he faced during the seven-year process, and surprising discoveries about American currency. The conversation also delves into the use of various forms of currency in colonial America, including barter systems, clamshells, tobacco, and the impact of counterfeiting. Additionally, they explore Benjamin Franklin's contributions to currency design and the historical significance of the Continental Dollar. In this conversation, Will and Tony explore the intricate history of American money, from the evolution of treasure fleets and the small change crisis in early America to the introduction of fiat currency and the establishment of the Federal Reserve. They discuss significant events like the Crime of 1873, the Confederate money system during the Civil War, and the modern treasure hunt for the Forest Fenn treasure. The conversation concludes with valuable advice for aspiring coin collectors, emphasizing the importance of knowledge and passion in the hobby.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to the Podcast and Guest
02:25 Motivation Behind Writing the Book
04:13 The Writing Process and Challenges
10:12 Goals and Objectives of the Book
12:17 Surprising Discoveries in American Money History
14:08 Currency in Colonial America
18:12 The Use of Clamshells and Beads as Currency
21:02 Tobacco as Currency in Virginia
22:55 Counterfeiting Throughout History
25:03 Benjamin Franklin's Contributions to Currency
26:59 The Continental Dollar and Its Impact
29:25 Spanish Gold and Silver Losses
30:14 The Evolution of Treasure Fleets
34:13 The Small Change Crisis in Early America
37:46 The Introduction of Fiat Currency
39:04 The Need for a Central Bank
41:49 The Crime of 1873 and Its Impact
46:22 The Confederate Money System During the Civil War
49:09 The Forest Fenn Treasure Hunt
53:30 Advice for Aspiring Coin Collectors

Where to find Will's book:
https://a.co/d/03nT6tAM

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins 

How to contact Will:
email: [email protected] 

Upcoming Shows:
https://cabbagecoins.com/coinshows/

Thanks for watching!

Intro/Outro Music - "Obverse Fields" by Timothy Gryckiewicz

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins Podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz welcomes Brandon Blakney to discuss Canadian numismatics. They explore Brandon's journey into coin collecting, the unique aspects of Canadian coins, and delve into specific examples such as Newfoundland's two dollar gold coins and the Voyager series. The conversation highlights the history, grading, and collecting strategies for Canadian coins, providing valuable insights for enthusiasts. In this conversation, they explore the intricacies of coin preservation and the importance of understanding historical context when evaluating coins. The discussion highlights the rarity and value of specific coins, particularly the 1948 dollar, which is considered the king of Canadian silver coins. Throughout the conversation, they emphasize the need for a holistic approach to grading and collecting, making it an educational experience for numismatics enthusiasts.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Numismatics and Canadian Coins
01:55 Brandon's Journey into Coin Collecting
05:10 Understanding Canadian Numismatics
09:04 Exploring Newfoundland's Two Dollar Gold Coins
19:34 The Voyager Series and Canadian Dollar Coins
26:25 Key Dates in Canadian Fifty Cent Coins
31:12 The Unique Twenty Cent Pieces of New Brunswick
40:05 Discovering Rare Coins
41:52 The Significance of Canadian Coins
44:47 Grading Challenges in Numismatics
49:02 Understanding Coin Preservation
51:52 The Importance of Historical Context
57:07 Identifying Key Dates in Coinage
64:35 The Evolution of Canadian Minting
69:29 The King of Canadian Silver Coins

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Where to find Brandon Blakney:
Email: [email protected]

Coin Show Schedule:
https://cabbagecoins.com/coinshows/

In this episode of the Cabbage Coins podcast, host Tony Gryckiewicz welcomes back Tony Littlejohn to discuss his journey in coin collecting, particularly focusing on the Everyman set and the nuances of AU58 and AU58+ coins. They explore the market trends, pricing, and the importance of eye appeal in coin grading, while also highlighting specific coins from Littlejohn's collection. The conversation also touches on the subjectivity of grading and the impact of registry sets on coin values. They explore strategies for auctioning collections, the challenges of competing with other collectors, and the significance of personal connections in the coin market. The discussion wraps up with reflections on future collecting plans and the unique experiences that come from engaging with the coin community.

Chapters
00:00 Introduction to Cabbage Coins Podcast
01:01 Tony Littlejohn's Coin Collecting Journey
02:22 Understanding the Everyman Set
05:21 The Evolution of the Everyman Collection
09:06 Market Trends and Pricing of AU58 Coins
15:11 The Appeal of AU58+ Coins
21:39 Highlights from the Collection
24:25 The Importance of Eye Appeal in Coins
30:53 Coin Collection Insights
34:46 The Value of Premium Coins
38:53 Exploring Gold Coins
42:21 Understanding Grading and Plus Coins
47:54 Subjectivity in Coin Grading
50:18 The Joy of Collecting Coins
53:00 Building and Valuing Coin Sets
56:25 The Auction Dilemma: Selling as a Set vs. Individually
60:51 Future Plans and Ongoing Collections
63:39 The Importance of Coin Shows
70:41 Closing Thoughts and Future Conversations

Where to find Tony and Cabbage Coins:
https://cabbagecoins.com/
Email: [email protected]
IG: @cabbage_coins

Check out www.cabbagecoins.com for great US numismatics