What does it mean to call America a Christian nation?

Tom Ascol delves into the complex topic of Christian nationalism, likening it to a wax nose that can be shaped to fit various agendas. Ascol questions the notion of America being in a special covenant with God, similar to Israel, and rejects extravagant political claims that suggest America has a divine destiny above other nations. He emphasizes that while America is a nation under God like any other, it does not have a unique covenantal relationship with Him.

Exploring definitions of Christian nationalism, Ascol finds it useful to adopt Paul Miller's perspective, which acknowledges America as an independent nation founded on Christian values. He agrees with the idea that it is the responsibility of both the government and the people to preserve these values today. While America was indeed founded by individuals who desired to honor God, Ascol acknowledges its imperfections, urging a balanced view that recognizes both historical sins and the nation's Christian influences.

Proverbs 14:34 (NKJV): "Righteousness exalts a nation, but sin is a reproach to any people."