Sign up to save your podcastsEmail addressPasswordRegisterOrContinue with GoogleAlready have an account? Log in here.
Joe and Kurt, two idiots who spend more time watching wrestling than anyone should, team up to talk the stories, matches, and fantasy booking of the week.... more
FAQs about The Cookie Sheets:How many episodes does The Cookie Sheets have?The podcast currently has 26 episodes available.
April 10, 2026Episode 291: It’s Vegas, BabyyyyJoe and Kurt start the show by diving into this weekend’s AEW Dynasty PPV. Then, it’s a new segment called Real Slams, Fake Bets – all about the two night Mania card.The post Episode 291: It’s Vegas, Babyyyy first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more46minPlay
March 20, 2026Episode 290: Still Not InterestedJoe and Kurt are back, and they’ve watched some wrestling. First up for discussion are the Mania card changes in the last few weeks. Is Orton challenging Rhodes uh, better than what it was going to be? Then it’s all about Revolution’s returns and the ending to the FORTY-SIX MINUTE death match.The post Episode 290: Still Not Interested first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more48minPlay
February 06, 2026Episode 289: I Wasted a FuboTV Trial on THIS??Joe has a list of grievances with the 2026 Royal Rumble event. A. LIST. Get ready to hear it. Also, AEW has some newcomers. Who will have the most imapct?The post Episode 289: I Wasted a FuboTV Trial on THIS?? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
January 23, 2026Episode 288: Rumbly in Our TumbliesThis week it’s all about the upcoming Royal Rumble event. Who will win? What surprises will we see? Which wrestler has the best odds? But first… chocolate talk?The post Episode 288: Rumbly in Our Tumblies first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more35minPlay
January 09, 2026Episode 287: 2025 Sheety AwardsJoe and Kurt are back in 2026! Joe plays “pick a number” with Kurt before the idiots dive into their best and worst of 2025.The post Episode 287: 2025 Sheety Awards first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more52minPlay
December 19, 2025Episode 286: The Time to Quit Is NowJoe and Kurt are here to discuss all the ins and outs of John Cena’s last match, a submission loss to GUNTHER. Was it the right call? Then it’s about AEW’s upcoming World’s End PPV and Sports Illustrated’s end of year wrestling awards.The post Episode 286: The Time to Quit Is Now first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more41minPlay
December 05, 2025Episode 285: Cereal JudgementJoe and Kurt have some WAR GAMES to chat about. Was it uh, meh? Also, we’ve got a Continental Classic starting and a Women’s tag tournament wrapping up in AEW. WRESTLING.The post Episode 285: Cereal Judgement first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more50minPlay
November 14, 2025Episode 284: November is for CagesJoe and Kurt are back this week to dive into The Last Time is Now tournament to crown John Cena’s final opponent. Then it’s all about being between AEW’s recent Blood and Guts show and WWE’s War Games PPV at the end of the month. Is it too much? Then Kurt riddles Joe with “Guess…The post Episode 284: November is for Cages first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
October 31, 2025Episode 283: Spooky IdiotsJoe and Kurt finally manage to record another episode. This week it’s about wtf is going on with WWE’s Wrestlemania 42 advertising as well as the exorbitant prices of the tickets. Then its onto Wrestledream and how the guys feel about starting a PPV mid-match and uh, trying to drown someone.The post Episode 283: Spooky Idiots first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
September 26, 2025Episode 282: Lame-a-PaloozaJoe and Kurt open the show needing to talk about everything Wrestlepalooza. Why did John Cena get squashed? Who does it benefit? How crazy is it that ESPN gave the show a C on their first time on the network? From there, it’s all about All Out and the many surprises of the night.The post Episode 282: Lame-a-Palooza first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
FAQs about The Cookie Sheets:How many episodes does The Cookie Sheets have?The podcast currently has 26 episodes available.