Sign up to save your podcastsEmail addressPasswordRegisterOrContinue with GoogleAlready have an account? Log in here.
Joe and Kurt, two idiots who spend more time watching wrestling than anyone should, team up to talk the stories, matches, and fantasy booking of the week.... more
FAQs about The Cookie Sheets:How many episodes does The Cookie Sheets have?The podcast currently has 15 episodes available.
August 29, 2025Episode 280: Le OuiJoe and Kurt are impressively here for a second week in a row! This week it’s the fallout from Forbidden Door. Who steps up for AEW with some of the top guys out? The WWE has a Clash in Paris event this weekend as well. Who takes the pin in the fatal four way? The post Episode 280: Le Oui first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
August 22, 2025Episode 279: Forbidden Door, Now With 46% More ForbiddenJoe and Kurt are back to talk the latest news with the WWE / ESPN / Peacock PLE announcements. How many things will we need to watch this company now? Then it’s onto AEW and previewing this weekend’s Forbidden Door PPV.The post Episode 279: Forbidden Door, Now With 46% More Forbidden first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more0minPlay
August 08, 2025Episode 278: WWE is Who We Thought They WereJoe and Kurt are here this week to talk about WWE. And how was they’re making it on Joe. He rants for a bit. First about Brock Lesnar’s return. And then about WWE and ESPN. And hey, he recently attended a couple of AEW’s residency shows in Chicago! That’s FUN.The post Episode 278: WWE is Who We Thought They Were first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more51minPlay
July 18, 2025Episode 277: Post-Too Much WrestlingJoe and Kurt are back! This week it’s about WWE’s Evolution PLE and how it stacks up versus the rest of their events this year so far. Then uh, Saturday Night’s Main Event I guess? Then it’s onto the long-ass show that was All In.The post Episode 277: Post-Too Much Wrestling first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more53minPlay
July 04, 2025Episode 276: Could There BE Any More July Wrestling?Joe and Kurt are finally back to get through all of the upcoming wrestling events the weekend of July 11th-13th. There are a LOT. But before that, “Basic Punkonomics” And then Kurt’s favorite, Goldberg.The post Episode 276: Could There BE Any More July Wrestling? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more49minPlay
June 13, 2025Episode 275: Truth Will Set You FreeJoe and Kurt are back to talk a surprising amount of happenings in wrestling. First off is the stunning release and re-hire of Ron Killings and HHH’s stupid press conference. Then it’s onto MITB results and Mariah May’s new identity in NXT.The post Episode 275: Truth Will Set You Free first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more54minPlay
May 30, 2025Episode 274: Staples EverywhereJoe and Kurt are here to talk AEW’s Double or Nothing. Did the right wrestlers win the Owen Cups? And how about that Anarchy in the Arena? Then it’s onto whatever the heck is happening in NXT these days.The post Episode 274: Staples Everywhere first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more47minPlay
May 09, 2025Episode 273: Everyone Looks WeakJoe and Kurt have a LOT of wrestling to talk about, but first on the firing list is the main event of Wrestlemania 41. From there it’s onto the rest of ‘Mania, a small Backlash preview, and wtf does WWE buying AAA mean?The post Episode 273: Everyone Looks Weak first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more1h 4minPlay
April 11, 2025A Heel Cheated? WHAT?Joe and Kurt are here to breakdown the “controversy” of the finish to AEW Dynasty’s Main Event. Also, whose new gear was the best? (Spoiler, it’s Adam Cole’s.) Then its onto Wrestlemania and the weird build of Charlotte v Tiffy.The post A Heel Cheated? WHAT? first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more52minPlay
April 04, 2025Episode 271: Game Show TimeJoe opens this week’s show by surprising Kurt with the brand new game show “Who’d You Rather Have?” In this game, Kurt decides if he prefers the WWE or AEW version of a wrestler’s career. Then it’s onto previewing this weekend’s AEW Dynasty PPV!Also some Discord-related difficulties in not hearing our really funny sound effects.The post Episode 271: Game Show Time first appeared on MostlyAverageJoe.com....more44minPlay
FAQs about The Cookie Sheets:How many episodes does The Cookie Sheets have?The podcast currently has 15 episodes available.