Step back into 1879 Atlanta, where an elderly pioneer couple met their brutal end in one of the city’s most chilling unsolved cases. Martin and Sarah DeFoor, respected early settlers who helped build Atlanta from its frontier roots, were savagely murdered with an axe on their own farm in an attack that shocked the growing Southern city. This is the story of a crime that exposed the limitations of 19th-century law enforcement, shattered a community’s sense of security, and left questions that remain unanswered over 145 years later. From the horrific discovery by neighbors to the theories about transients, robbery, and dark secrets, explore every angle of a case that has been nearly forgotten by history but deserves to be remembered.

Join us as we examine the evidence, explore the suspects, and uncover why this brutal double homicide was never solved. We’ll transport you to post-Civil War Atlanta, where gas lamps flickered on dirt roads and justice often proved elusive. Through careful historical research and period accounts, we reconstruct the final hours of the DeFoors’ lives and the investigation that followed. This is more than just a true crime story—it’s a glimpse into Atlanta’s hidden past and a reminder that some mysteries endure forever, leaving only names on street signs and whispers in the archives.

#TrueCrime #UnsolvedMystery #AtlantaHistory #ColdCase #AxeMurder #1800s #VictorianCrime #SouthernHistory #TrueCrimePodcast #UnsolvedMurders #HistoricalCrime #AtlantaColdCase #DeFoorMurders #CivilWarEra #CrimeHistory #MurderMystery​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

In the shadow of the White House, a shocking crime of passion erupted on a calm Sunday in 1859: Congressman Daniel Sickles gunned down Philip Barton Key—son of the man who wrote “The Star-Spangled Banner”—in broad daylight in Lafayette Square.

Fueled by betrayal, adultery, and rage, the brazen murder stunned antebellum America and led to the most explosive trial of the era.

This is the story of the nation’s first successful temporary insanity defense—the legal bombshell that let a killer walk free and forever changed criminal justice.

Sex, scandal, honor, and history’s most audacious acquittal—don’t miss this gripping tale of murder right across from the President’s doorstep. Hit play now and discover why this case still echoes today.

#TrueCrime #HistoricalTrueCrime #MurderMystery #TemporaryInsanity #CrimeHistory #LafayetteSquare #WhiteHouse #Scandal #19thCentury #TrueCrimePodcast #HistoryPodcast

August 10, 1884. A quiet farmhouse in Lewis County, Tennessee. When two young Mormon missionaries arrived seeking converts, they had no idea their mission would end in bloodshed. Within months, an armed mob stormed the home where they were staying, leaving four people dead and shattering a community forever. One missionary, just 20 years old, never made it home. Another escaped into the woods, wounded and running for his life.

This is the shocking true story of religious violence in post-Civil War America—a forgotten massacre that exposed the deadly consequences of fear, prejudice, and mob justice. Discover what really happened when faith communities collided in the rural South, why neighbors turned into killers, and how this tragedy changed Mormon missionary work forever. A gripping tale of persecution, survival, and the dark side of American religious history.

⚠️ Content Warning: Contains descriptions of violence and religious persecution.

#TrueCrime #History #AmericanHistory #MormonHistory #Tennessee #ReligiousHistory

Join Deuce Conrad as we separate myth from truth and explore why, 135 years later, Belle Starr’s murder remains one of America’s most compelling cold cases.

#TrueCrime #BelleStarr #UnsolvedMystery #OldWest #BanditQueen #ColdCase #IndianTerritory #FrontierJustice #WildWest #CrimeHistory #MurderMystery #1889 #Oklahoma #FemaleOutlaw #TheWildWest #HistoricalCrime #AmericanHistory #Outlaws #UnsolvedMurder #TrueCrimePodcast #DeucConradShow #ForgottenCrimes #YoundersBend #WesternHistory #CrimePodcast

Join Deuce Conrad as we examine how wealth and privilege shaped justice in 1920s America, explore the limitations of early forensic science, and ask the haunting question that remains unanswered over a century later: who really killed Janette Lawrence?

#TrueCrime #JanetteLawrence #UnsolvedMystery #ColdCase #1921 #MadisonNJ #NewJersey #ClassPrivilege #JusticeSystem #BoyScout #HistoricalCrime #ForgottenCrimes #UnsolvedMurder #TrueCrimePodcast #DeuceConradShow #1920s #ForensicScience #CriminalJustice #AmericanHistory #MurderMystery #KluxenWoods #ClassInequality #FrontierJustice #ColdCaseFiles #TrueCrimeHistory

Explore one of Gilded Age Indiana’s most sensational small‑town cases as The Deuce Conrad Show investigates the Pettit murder trial, where the 1889 death of Hattie Pettit led to accusations that her husband, Reverend William “Fred” Pettit—a respected minister and Freemason—poisoned her amid rumors of an affair, a tainted cup of tea, and a community determined to force justice from its courts and its pulpit.

🎙️ New Episode Alert!

When terrorists threaten to destroy Redstone Arsenal, one man stands in their way. Deuce Conrad is back, taking down threats with precision, grit, and a whole lot of nerve. Tune in to hear the pulse-pounding story of The Redstone Gambit!

🔗 Listen now

#Podcast #Thriller #ActionPacked #DeuceConrad #MilitaryFiction #Suspense #HeroStories #RedstoneArsenal #NewEpisode

“In the heart of Walker County, Alabama, where the woods whisper and the mines hide secrets, private investigator Deuce Conrad uncovers a chilling mystery. Young men vanish, symbols mark the walls, and whispers of The Hollow Men haunt the land. Some places hold darkness too deep to escape. Will Deuce survive the truth buried beneath Walker County?

Listen to the ‘Mysteries of Walker County’ — a Southern noir tale of murder, mystery, and the secrets that refuse to stay buried.”

#SouthernGothic #NoirFiction #MysteryStory #WalkerCounty #CrimeThriller #DarkTales #HollowMen #SmallTownSecrets #DetectiveStory #ShortStory

🎙️ New Episode Alert! 🎙️

In The Steel City Scandal, private investigator Deuce Conrad takes on a corrupt councilman in Birmingham, Alabama. Millions stolen, lives threatened, and secrets buried—until now. A tense story of greed, danger, and justice in a city built on steel and shadow.

🔗 Listen now wherever you get your podcasts!

#TrueCrimePodcast #DetectiveStories #SouthernNoir #CrimeThriller #CorruptionExposed #BirminghamAL #PIStories #JusticeServed #PodcastEpisode #MysteryAndCrime

🔍 Graveyards, Rituals, and Secrets Buried Deep…

Private investigator Deuce Conrad takes on a chilling case in Huntsville’s Maple Hill Cemetery, where grave robbers are stealing bodies—but it’s not jewelry they’re after. An abandoned mausoleum, cloaked figures, and an ancient ritual book reveal a dark mystery that should have stayed buried.

Some secrets are better left in the grave.

#Mystery #HorrorStory #GraveyardTales #PrivateInvestigator #DeuceConrad #MapleHill