We’re moving away from natural disasters and peering into the life of a self-proclaimed cult leader, Benny Evangelista, and his family--the victims of a gruesome crime that occurred in 1929. The St. Aubin Avenue Massacre is one of Michigan's most harrowing cases, and it remains unsolved. With the patriarch believing in odd things and strange practices, police aren't sure what's a clue and what’s not as they venture into the Evangelista's home for answers.