July 1, 1976. Bavaria, Germany. Twenty-three-year-old Anneliese Michel dies weighing 68 pounds after 67 exorcism sessions over ten months. Her parents and two Catholic priests believed they were saving her soul from demonic possession. Medical professionals believed she was a mentally ill young woman who needed psychiatric care.

This Halloween, we present both sides with equal weight—the evidence for possession and the psychological explanations—without dismissing either. We explore disturbing audio recordings, witness testimonies about simultaneous voices and unexplained knowledge, reactions to blessed objects, and predictions that came true. We also examine epilepsy, dissociative disorders, and how culture shapes mental illness.

The result? You'll leave more uncertain than when you started. And that uncertainty might be the scariest thing of all.

WHAT WE COVER: The 67 documented exorcism sessions | Evidence that challenges natural explanation | Simultaneous speaking in multiple voices | Knowledge she shouldn't have possessed | Psychological frameworks (epilepsy, dissociative disorders) | Cultural shaping of mental illness | Catholic exorcism criteria | Why certainty on either side can be dangerous | Whether mental illness and possession could coexist

THE DISTURBING EVIDENCE: Audio recordings of exorcisms exist | Multiple witnesses to unexplained phenomena | Reactions to blessed objects vs. placebos | Speaking languages she never studied | Detailed knowledge of events she couldn't know | Physical strength beyond her emaciated state | Predictions that later came true | Medical diagnoses that didn't fully explain symptoms

SOURCES: Goodman, F.D. "The Exorcism of Anneliese Michel" (1981) | Trial transcripts, District Court of Aschaffenburg (1978) | Devinsky & Lai: "Spirituality and Religion in Epilepsy," Epilepsy & Behavior (2008) | Catholic exorcism criteria: Rituale Romanum & Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith | American Psychiatric Association DSM-5 (Dissociative Identity Disorder) | Seligman & Kirmayer: "Dissociative experience and cultural neuroscience," Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry (2008) | Medical and psychological journal research on temporal lobe epilepsy and religious experiences

CONTENT WARNING: Discussion of mental illness, religious trauma, starvation, and death. Listener discretion advised.

DISCLAIMER: For educational/entertainment purposes only. Based on trial transcripts, medical literature, and published research. We are not medical professionals, clergy, or mental health experts. This episode presents multiple perspectives without declaring definitive conclusions. Views expressed explore complex intersections of faith, medicine, and psychology. We treat Anneliese Michel and her family with respect while examining this case's difficult questions. This is not an endorsement of either supernatural or purely medical explanations.

FAIR WARNING: This episode doesn't provide easy answers. We don't conclude she was possessed, and we don't conclude she was "just" mentally ill. We sit with the discomfort of not knowing, because sometimes intellectual honesty means admitting the limits of our understanding.

Happy Halloween. Question your certainties.

Send us your theories

Support the show

👀 Want more? Follow us @MugshotMysteries on TikTok and Instagram for case photos, crime scene breakdowns, and stories too wild for the full episode.

⭐ Leave a rating—it helps other true crime obsessives find us.

🎧 New episodes drop weekly on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and everywhere you listen.

Stay curious. Stay suspicious. See you next week with another face... and another mystery