Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share The Faithfulness of What Falls Between
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
The Faithfulness of What Falls Between
Summary
In this episode, we explore a common "quiet anxiety" in the spiritual life: the suspicion that the manner of our arrival—whether through a direct divine summons or a desperate flight from catastrophe—defines our ultimate spiritual prospects. Drawing on the wisdom of the desert father Abba Paphnutius, we examine three types of callings and learn why the "how" of our beginning matters far less than the faithfulness of the journey that follows.
Key Discussion Points
The Three Types of Calling: Abba Paphnutius identifies three distinct ways an individual is drawn to the spiritual life:
Direct from God: An interior inspiration or "piercing awareness" of one's need, occurring without human mediation (e.g., Abraham or Abba Antony).
Through a "Credible Witness": Being drawn to God through the example or advice of another holy person (e.g., the Israelites through Moses, or Cassian and Germanus).
Through Catastrophe: Arriving "against our will" due to the collapse of health, wealth, or the loss of loved ones (e.g., the patterns found in the Book of Judges).
The Myth of the "Hierarchy of Callings": While religious communities often prize dramatic testimonies, Paphnutius insists there is no hierarchy. A noble beginning offers no protection against spiritual "torpor" (as seen in Judas), while a coerced beginning can be transformed into a journey of total freedom (as seen in Paul or Abba Moses the Ethiopian).
The Theology of the "Cell": Moving from flight to journey requires inhabiting our current state fully. We reflect on the desert father's rule—"Stay in your cell, and your cell will teach you everything"—as a call to embrace the "thisness and nowness" of our lives rather than trying to flee them.
The Importance of the "End": Paphnutius concludes that everything depends upon the end, not the beginning. Spiritual success is found in the "long and mostly unglamorous middle" between our first summons and our last breath.
Notable Quotes
"What brings us to the door does not determine what we will find inside, or how far we will be willing to go once we enter."
"To the natural mind, a boundary is a confinement. To the spiritual mind, a boundary is a sanctuary."
Resources Mentioned
St. Cassian’s Third Conference: Specifically chapters 3–5.
Scriptural Figures: Abraham, Antony of Egypt, Moses, Judas, and St. Paul.
Spiritual Teachers: St. Seraphim of Sarov, Servant of God Catherine Doherty (The Duty of the Moment), and Abba Moses the Ethiopian.
Scripture References: Psalm 16, Psalm 78 (the Psalmist), and the Book of Judges.
Next Steps
In our next episode, we will continue our journey with Abba Paphnutius as he expounds upon the three renunciations—the heart of the spiritual work required for the journey.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit forestandsilence.substack.com
View all episodes
By Desert Spirituality for the Modern Wilderness.Summary
In this episode, we explore a common "quiet anxiety" in the spiritual life: the suspicion that the manner of our arrival—whether through a direct divine summons or a desperate flight from catastrophe—defines our ultimate spiritual prospects. Drawing on the wisdom of the desert father Abba Paphnutius, we examine three types of callings and learn why the "how" of our beginning matters far less than the faithfulness of the journey that follows.
Key Discussion Points
The Three Types of Calling: Abba Paphnutius identifies three distinct ways an individual is drawn to the spiritual life:
Direct from God: An interior inspiration or "piercing awareness" of one's need, occurring without human mediation (e.g., Abraham or Abba Antony).
Through a "Credible Witness": Being drawn to God through the example or advice of another holy person (e.g., the Israelites through Moses, or Cassian and Germanus).
Through Catastrophe: Arriving "against our will" due to the collapse of health, wealth, or the loss of loved ones (e.g., the patterns found in the Book of Judges).
The Myth of the "Hierarchy of Callings": While religious communities often prize dramatic testimonies, Paphnutius insists there is no hierarchy. A noble beginning offers no protection against spiritual "torpor" (as seen in Judas), while a coerced beginning can be transformed into a journey of total freedom (as seen in Paul or Abba Moses the Ethiopian).
The Theology of the "Cell": Moving from flight to journey requires inhabiting our current state fully. We reflect on the desert father's rule—"Stay in your cell, and your cell will teach you everything"—as a call to embrace the "thisness and nowness" of our lives rather than trying to flee them.
The Importance of the "End": Paphnutius concludes that everything depends upon the end, not the beginning. Spiritual success is found in the "long and mostly unglamorous middle" between our first summons and our last breath.
Notable Quotes
"What brings us to the door does not determine what we will find inside, or how far we will be willing to go once we enter."
"To the natural mind, a boundary is a confinement. To the spiritual mind, a boundary is a sanctuary."
Resources Mentioned
St. Cassian’s Third Conference: Specifically chapters 3–5.
Scriptural Figures: Abraham, Antony of Egypt, Moses, Judas, and St. Paul.
Spiritual Teachers: St. Seraphim of Sarov, Servant of God Catherine Doherty (The Duty of the Moment), and Abba Moses the Ethiopian.
Scripture References: Psalm 16, Psalm 78 (the Psalmist), and the Book of Judges.
Next Steps
In our next episode, we will continue our journey with Abba Paphnutius as he expounds upon the three renunciations—the heart of the spiritual work required for the journey.
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit forestandsilence.substack.com