On their very first date, Cheryl and Charlie both had the same goal: make a good impression. Charlie arrived ready to “woo her off her feet,” and Cheryl did her best to order something reasonably priced—despite a menu with no prices in sight. What followed was a confident (and slightly misguided) order of foie gras… by both of them.

It’s the kind of beginning where nothing goes exactly right—and somehow, everything does.