The 2025 New Jersey gubernatorial race has been upended by a decades-old scandal. U.S. Naval Academy alumnus and Heritage Foundation expert Brent Sadler joins Matt to discuss Mikie Sherrill's role in the historic cheating incident and what it might tell us about his former classmate's character. ALSO: a Schumer Shutdown update, a "racist" birthday song controversy in Florida, and Producer Dan explains his favorite (and exceptionally peculiar) Spooky Season tradition.