How is the IT asset disposition and electronics recycling doing as we close the year 2023?  What is certain is that by the time industry stakeholders took our third quarter survey, they already had clear visibility on how the year will end. And I can say that one way of describing the ending is that the glass is both half full and half empty. Half full, because many ITADs, if not most, may have met their revenue targets. Half empty because profitability projections may not have been met. So most in the industry will probably move to 2024 largely unscathed and likely ready to fight another year, but there are not enough profits to say real value was created during the year and so goes the year-end bonuses.