Johnny Dollar travels to the New England coast to investigate a mysterious insurance claim tied to a dilapidated mansion and its eccentric, reclusive owner—Jack Madigan. Once a famed Broadway producer, Madigan now lives in seclusion with a loyal housekeeper and a string of unanswered questions. As Johnny uncovers the truth behind forged documents, unexplained fires, and missing jewels, he learns that Madigan’s past may be haunting him in more ways than one. When a stranger appears with ties to a decades-old scandal, Johnny must determine if the truth is buried beneath the floorboards—or hidden in plain sight.

Cast: Edmund O’Brien, Virginia Gregg, John Dehner, Jeanette Nolan, Howard McNear, Larry Dobkin