Send us a text

A girl goes missing. A dog comes home with a human arm. And a jagged cliffside called “The Devil’s Teeth” becomes the epicenter of one of New Jersey’s most unsettling mysteries.

In the summer of 1972, 16-year-old Jeanette DePalma vanished on her way to a friend’s house. Six weeks later, her decomposed body was discovered atop a jagged bluff — surrounded by rumors, strange symbols, and a town quick to blame the victim.

With no clear cause of death, the autopsy raised more questions than answers. The media chased a Satanic narrative. And Jeanette? She was buried beneath a story that never truly honored who she was.

Support the show