Producer Paul Moak knows you hate Collapsible Lung. Brad Wilson has a eulogy for the band we all loved. Both help us decide which song is a contender for Relient K's best song.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

0:34 Guest 1: Brad Wilson

2:41 The Album: Forget

12:29 Guest 2: Paul Moak

30:32 1st Nomination

55:33 2nd Nomination

1:00:58 3rd Nomination

1:08:54 4th Nomination

1:17:27 Debate Begins

1:32:24 Plugs & Previews

Matt Hoopes is in the house with takes on Forget and Not Slow Down. We hear his biggest regret (Katy Perry is involved), how Matt Thiessen met Owl City (Katy Perry is not), and a little bit about what's next for Relient K.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

0:21 The Guest: Matt Hoopes

2:41 The Album: Forget

21:45 Is everything pre-MMHMM trash?

45:08 1st Nomination

50:09 2nd Nomination

55:56 3rd Nomination

1:00:23 4th Nomination

1:08:00 Debate Begins

1:24:24 Plugs & Previews

We're here with Josh Auer to decide the best song on Relient K's Five Score & Seven Years Ago. Will we leave another favorite in the dust?

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

0:21 The Guest: Josh Auer

9:49 The Album: Five Score

24:02 Jesus or My Girlfriend

30:36 1st Nomination

38:40 2nd Nomination

45:43 3rd Nomination

53:13 4th Nomination

57:43 Debate Begins

1:13:11 Plugs & Previews

Producer Mark Lee Townsend taps in to help choose the best song on Relient K's landmark album, MMHMM. No one knows this band like Mark.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

05:31 The Making of MMHMM with Mark Lee Townsend

20:40 Jesus or My Girlfriend

33:28 1st Nomination

38:35 2nd Nomination

43:45 3rd Nomination

49:22 4th Nomination

56:21 Debate Begins

1:08:05 Plugs & Previews

1:12:39 Secret Track: Mark Lets It All Out

Whitney Lane Wiley joins to help us sort through the twists, turns, and many moods of Two Lefts Don't Make a Right...But Three Do.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

0:25 The Guest: Whitney Lane Wiley

1:45 The Album: Two Lefts

13:43 Jesus or My Girlfriend

30:52 1st Nomination

35:49 2nd Nomination

42:05 3rd Nomination

54:16 2nd 3rd Nomination

59:34 4th Nomination

1:05:49 Debate Begins

1:15:46 Plugs & Previews

Sam Barnhart of Bleach joins to help choose the best song on The Anatomy of the Tongue in Cheek. We meet our first heavy hitters.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.

TIMESTAMPS

0:00 Intro

1:00 The Guest: Sam Barnhart

4:51 The Album: Anatomy

34:45 The Great Sadie Truce of 2026

40:54 2nd Nomination

43:33 3rd Nomination

52:10 4th Nomination

56:12 What's the WORST song on Anatomy?

1:01:29 Debate Begins

1:14:12 Secret Track: What has Sam been doing lately?

Addison and Will have to agree on the best song from Relient K's debut album. Options are sparse.

Comment below to tell us we're wrong and to nominate a song for resurrection at the end of the season! We're also on socials @thelockinsongs.

Click here for a playlist of all nominated songs so far this season.