Would you dare play a game that invites a demon into your home? Or balance two pencils to summon a spirit that never leaves? In this episode of Make You Scream, Nicki Baber takes you deep into the terrifying world of The Midnight Man ritual and the viral Charlie Charlie Challenge.

We’ll explore:

• The chilling step-by-step rules of The Midnight Man game

• The psychology of why candlelight, salt, and 3:33 AM feel so dangerous

• The real reason pencils move during Charlie Charlie

• Viral stories, urban legends, and why these games spread like wildfire on TikTok and YouTube

If you’ve ever whispered “Charlie Charlie, are you here?” or thought about summoning the Midnight Man, this episode will make you think twice.

👻 New episodes every Monday at 1PM EST.
Submit your story at makeyouscreampodcast.com.