Halloween should be a fun time for kids. They get to dress up in costumes, go trick-or-treating with their friends, and eat candy all night long. But on Halloween night in 1974, 8-year-old Timothy O'Bryan had his last candy hunt. While Timothy is going house-to-house filling his bag with candy, he gets home and his father lets him choose one piece of candy before bed. Timothy chooses a large pixy stix. Shortly after eating the candy, Timothy becomes ill.....and actually ends up dying. The candy he chose to eat that night was found to have been poisoned. Was Timothy the intended target? And WHO would poison a child?