Gerardo and Carly kick off the season by exploring the highs and lows of love during the holidays. Carly learns a harsh truth: all gifts are returnable—and sometimes, you don’t even get to open them. Meanwhile, Gerardo shares tales of his mom’s Christmas adventure in New York, proving it might just be a festive circle of hell. Together, they rethink their approach to New Year’s resolutions and hope these will stick.

Got a first love story? Email us at [email protected]—we’d love to hear from you!