In this episode of Pieces of History, I’m heading into the shadow world of organised crime with crime historian and author Scott M. Deitche, whose books and documentaries have become essential reading for anyone interested in the American Mafia. From Garden State Gangland to Cigar City Mafia and The Silent Don, Scott has built a career uncovering stories hidden in court files, surveillance tapes, and long-forgotten archives.

Our conversation focuses on the DeCavalcante crime family of New Jersey — a lesser-known but powerful organisation that operated alongside New York’s syndicates while carving out its own territory in Newark and Elizabeth. Scott charts their rise, internal tensions, brushes with law enforcement, and gradual decline, revealing how leadership, loyalty, and paranoia shaped their fate.

We also explore the challenges of researching groups built on secrecy, and the family’s pop-culture shadow through The Sopranos.

It’s a story of myth versus reality, and of how even the most hidden worlds leave a paper trail — if you know where to look.

Email: [email protected]

Facebook: Pieces of History podcast

Instagram: @pieceofhistorypod

Scott M. Deitche - Tampa Mafia - tampamafia.com