Arthur Brill's (Episode 6) analysis of Part 3, Question 3 of the New York State Regents examination for English Language Arts (ELA 11) leaves little doubt that Question 3, not the test itself, is unequivocally fair and appropriate.  However, the Petition, signed by 40,000 people presumably acting in the best interest of education, should raise 40,000 questions.

Link to the Petition signed by the 40,000

https://www.change.org/p/new-york-state-education-department-do-not-count-part-3-on-the-nys-english-regents

Link to Jeff Peyton’s Petition initially signed by 300 teachers in two days

https://www.change.org/p/it-is-time-to-adopt-an-american-declaration-and-education-bill-of-rights