Send us Fan Mail

John Ondo, a 40-year TV and filmmaking veteran, compares HBO’s The Pitt and Paramount’s Star Trek: Starfleet Academy—both are teacher-and-student shows with very different outcomes—to explain what content creators can learn about respecting audiences. He argues The Pit succeeds by trusting viewers with real-time, authentic hospital storytelling, minimal handholding, and relatable characters with consequences, helping it become a top streaming hit with broad demographic appeal (75% 30+; 10 million weekly global viewers). In contrast, he says Starfleet Academy tells viewers what to feel, violates core Star Trek principles, targets youth while alienating legacy fans, and has seen viewership drop from 2.1 million to under 200,000. Key takeaways: respect the audience, build real characters instead of message vehicles, and don’t chase demographics—tell universal human stories. #thepitt #startrek #starfleetacademy #contentcreators #television #mediainfluencer #writing #media #MediaTips #AudienceEngagement #ondomedia #podcast

00:00 Two Shows One Lesson
00:23 Host Intro And Setup
01:41 Why The Pit Works
04:40 Why Starfleet Academy Fails
05:43 Authenticity And Audience Respect
07:43 Demographics And Ratings Reality
08:45 Creator Takeaways
10:15 Wrap Up And Subscribe

Watch all of the video format of this podcast on my YouTube Channel.

https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLMqz-XMZ8v2VLfSXSCrEtDmfKum5g5ZEb