After a failed first attempt at a Punisher movie, The Punisher received a reboot in 2004. Now played by Thomas Jane, fans generally regard this as the most successful film adaptation. But it's not without its detractors, and some fans have never jived with this version's morose tone, casting choices, and origin story approach.

But what do Gabe and Connor think of this polarizing version? Get your land mines ready, 'cause it's about to go down.