Originally Aired: November 6, 1955

In Gunsmoke #187, “The Second Choice,” Marshal Matt Dillon faces a moral and legal dilemma when Andy Hill, a reformed fugitive living a quiet life in Dodge, is suddenly accused of murder in Oklahoma Territory. As Matt seeks the truth behind the charge, a mysterious deputy arrives with a warrant—but the story doesn’t add up. As suspicions grow, so does the danger. When deceit and vengeance collide, Matt must act quickly to prevent a wrongful conviction—or worse. A tense episode exploring justice, trust, and the fine line between law and personal loyalty.

Cast: William Conrad, Sam Edwards, Vic Perron, Joseph Kearns

Tags:

western, justice, lawman, betrayal, fugitiveredemption, falseidentity, WilliamConrad, oldtimeradio, Gunsmoke, DodgeCity, retribution, 1950sradio, classicdrama, suspensepodcast, radioadventure