What happens when your dream home becomes a nightmare? The Broaddus learned the hard way in 2014 when their New Jersey abode came with increasingly creepy letters from a stalker known only as "The Watcher". The experience was so intrusive and chilling that they never even fully moved into the house. Was The Watcher a local prankster, a ghoulish remnant of residents' past or something even more sinister? The fam moves in next door to this suburban mystery.