Tim drops by to talk about two films by an up and coming director (Robert Eggers, not David as I incorrectly call him in this episode), The Witch and The Lighthouse. Tim talks about the reasons why he has so much love for The Witch, while I discuss why it didn't quite stick for me, including repeating the same point several times! I also talk about why I like The Lighthouse so much and why I think it's the superior film. Will Tim be able to convince me to give it another chance like Mike convinced me to give Hereditary a second viewing? Presented by Timotheories.