Alyssa seems normal. Alyssa seems friendly. She smiles at parties. She remembers birthdays. She volunteers at the animal shelter. But everyone who spends too much time with Alyssa notices it. A darkness hiding just behind the smile. A coldness behind the eyes. Alyssa is not what she seems.

In this episode, I examine the case of Alyssa, a woman who hid a horrifying secret behind a mask of normalcy. Neighbors described her as helpful. Coworkers described her as kind. Family members described her as loving. Then police found the bodies. Alyssa had been killing for years. She had hidden the remains in places no one thought to look. The basement. The backyard. The crawlspace. Alyssa was not a monster in a mask. She was the girl next door.

The episode explores the psychology of killers who hide in plain sight. They are not social outcasts. They are not mentally ill. They are charming. They are likable. They are trusted. That is what makes them so dangerous. The episode also examines the investigation that finally exposed Alyssa. A single mistake. A overlooked detail. A witness who remembered something odd. The mask slipped. The truth emerged.

Turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and press play because there is something creepy about Alyssa. And you would never know it by looking at her.

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/red-tree-crime--6847553/support.