Emo Book Club returns with They’re Only Chasing Safety by Underoath—an album the boys both loved in their later high school years. Does it still hit the same, and is it their best? Also: an embarrassing story from Sam, Jayson going full emo, listener comments, Book Club considerations and tons of hilarious highschool stories.

Next week’s album: Colorblind by Seaway.

Get the rating guide at poppunkbookclub.com to rate along with us.