Back in town for nearly a year now, Penelope and Mels are dealing with the aftermath of the events in season one. Now, armed with the determination to learn about the true history of the town and it's founding members, they go over document after document in search of the truth, no matter how bad it may be. 

In this episode, Penelope goes over a journal entry by a Silverton and a letter from a Mullins, and wonders just how innocent these families really were.