It’s a cozy-spooky Halloween at Gravestone: Megan & Arthur hit record on Halloween night and switch things up with a storytelling game, each brings three short scary tales: two based in fact, one pure fiction. The other has to spot the fake…to win the pot of candy. Play along!

Highlights we talk through:

• Chelsea’s 1981 Halloween murders and those strange Son of Sam prison whispers about a planned double murder. What was real, what was rumor?
• The bloodied nightgown visitor sitting on a porch swing with a knife—was it a prank, a breakdown…or something worse?
• A supposed Niagara-side disappearance with puzzling clues and conflicting theories. Coincidence—or cover?
• The tragic Halloween-night case of Martha Moxley—and why it still lingers.

Tell us which story you think was fake and drop your own creepy mini-tales. We’re @GravestonePod everywhere. Also, expect more than movies here, books, games, and horror in every format are coming. Stay scared and stay tuned.

Follow us & Subscribe:

• Spotify
• Apple Podcast
• TikTok
• Instagram
• Threads

See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.