Ashley tells Jess about the 2011 murder of Garrett Phillips and the vitriol that become focused on Oral “Nick” Hillary in the small community of Potsdam, New York in the aftermath. Did police focus their efforts on one suspect too soon? Is there enough evidence to identify the killer? Will we ever know what happened inside Apartment 4D? We explore these questions and more.

If you have story requests reach out to us at [email protected]
-----------
Our Links:
Facebook link - facebook.com/StudyingScarletPodcast
Patreon: patreon.com/StudyingScarletPodcast
Twitter - twitter.com/StudyScarletPod
Instagram - instagram.com/studyingscarletpodcast
Teepublic - StudyingScarlet