Matthew breaks down how Paranormal Activity genuinely unsettled him, and that confession kicks off a conversation about why psychological horror sticks way longer than jump scares. He and Jacob move from childhood fears to horror classics and what actually makes something feel terrifying.

OUR DISCORD IS LIVE!!! 

WE GOT AN ALBUM ON Apple Music & Spotify NOW!!!

Follow us on X @TalkTrubbishPod

Subscribe to our Youtube @TalkingTrubbish

Email us your stories or questions!

[email protected]

00:00–03:08 Intro, catching up, tech/audio nonsense

03:08–05:39 Matthew watches Paranormal Activity for the first time

05:39–06:40 Movie premise: couple, haunting, and the camera setup

06:40–08:09 Psychic/“expert” visit, demon talk, and disbelief vs belief

08:09–13:58 Escalation nights, relationship tension, and building dread

13:58–16:26 The flour scene and the invisible footprints reveal

16:26–18:52 Why paranormal horror is scarier than zombies (no defense)

18:52–23:50 Climax/end talk, Matthew panic-level fear, sleep getting wrecked

23:50–26:58 Filmmaking praise: $15k budget, practical effects, Hollywood laziness

26:58–28:44 The Descent and “flashlight horror”

28:44–32:53 Horror games: Dead by Daylight and being scared on purpose

32:53–34:24 Night paranoia: taking the trash out and acting tough

34:24–37:03 Matthew’s basement/laundry scares and the picture-falling moment

37:03–41:53 Home-at-night fear, dogs as security, and recovery after the movie

41:53–44:39 Not antagonizing anything: cameras/webcams and “nope” behavior

44:39–50:51 Ouija boards, ghosts, and what they won’t mess with

50:51–58:15 Sleep paralysis, sleeping habits, and nighttime fear logic

58:15–End Wrap-up and setting up deeper paranormal talk later

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.