In this episode of Murder Pie, we examine the unsolved 1994 disappearance and murder of 19-year-old Melissa Witt in Fort Smith, Arkansas. After vanishing from a busy parking lot in the early evening, Melissa’s remains were later discovered deep in the Ozark National Forest — leaving behind decades of unanswered questions. We walk through the timeline, investigation, arrests, and lingering theories in a case that continues to haunt her family and community, then close the episode with a classic Arkansas-style apple pie recipe.