What if a fire tore through your home on Christmas Eve… and when the smoke cleared, five of your children were simply gone? No bodies. No remains. Just vanished. This episode explores the haunting mystery surrounding the Sodder children in Fayetteville, West Virginia, 1945.

George and Jennie Sodder, Italian immigrants raising ten kids, faced a nightmare when a Christmas Eve fire consumed their home. While the fire destroyed the house, five of the children—Betty, Jennie, Louis, Martha, and Maurice—were never found. From strange phone calls and missing ladders to a frozen water barrel and a cut phone line, the night was filled with unexplained obstacles and suspicious circumstances.

Despite official reports citing faulty wiring, no evidence of the children was ever recovered. Over decades, the Sodders pursued every lead—from alleged sightings to private investigators and even mysterious photographs—refusing to accept the official story. This episode delves into the events, theories, and ongoing fascination with one of America’s most enduring cold cases.

If you have any information, no matter how small, speak up. Every detail could help bring answers to this decades-old mystery. 

Listen, share, and keep the Sodder children’s story alive.