George Thomas praises the movie "Conclave," highlighting its exceptional cast, including Ralph Fiennes, John Lithgow and Stanley Tucci, and its balanced portrayal of the process of choosing a new pope, addressing both the church's virtues and vices. The film is thought-provoking, explores political intrigue, and delves into the crisis of faith of one man. Speaker 1 believes it deserves its eight Oscar nominations, including for Best Picture, despite the absence of director Edward Berger in the Best Director category. Craig Shoup agrees, noting the film's old-school drama appeal and its potential as a contender for Best Picture, despite the challenge posed by the lack of a directing nomination.