Hallel Fellowship

When free will meets God’s purpose: How Heaven orchestrates salvation (Genesis 44–46; Joshua 14; Luke 24)


Listen Later

7 takeaways from this study

  1. True repentance and maturity are shown through Judah’s transformation — from selfishness to sacrificial love for his family.
  2. God rewards wholehearted devotion, as seen in Caleb’s unwavering faith and eventual inheritance of Hebron.
  3. Suffering and waiting often precede glory; Joseph, Caleb, and Yeshua each endured hardship before receiving honor and fulfilling their purpose.
  4. Emotional honesty and humility, like Judah’s plea, can be more powerful than logical arguments in seeking mercy and reconciliation.
  5. God masterfully weaves our free will choices — both good and bad — into His greater redemptive plan.
  6. Unity and standing together, as the brothers did for Benjamin, reflect spiritual growth and are essential for God’s people.
  7. Choosing God’s will over personal desires leads to blessing, growth, and participation in His unfolding story of salvation.
  8. Today, I want to invite you into a journey through three powerful biblical narratives — Joseph and his brothers (Genesis 44–46), Caleb’s inheritance (Joshua 14), and the walk to Emmaus with Yeshua (Jesus) (Luke 24). Each story is unique, yet together they reveal a profound pattern: suffering, testing, and waiting often precede glory, restoration, and fulfillment in God’s plan. As we explore these passages, let’s look for the threads of repentance, wholehearted faith, and God’s sovereign orchestration — concepts deeply rooted in both the TaNaKh and the Brit Chadashah (New Testament).

    Judah’s Plea: The Power of Repentance and Emotional Honesty

    (Genesis 44:18–34)

    Let’s begin with Judah’s impassioned plea before Joseph. The context is tense: Benjamin has been accused of theft, and the brothers stand before the Egyptian ruler — unaware that he is their own brother, Joseph, whom they betrayed years earlier.

    Judah steps forward and delivers what I believe is one of the most heartfelt and honest arguments in all of Scripture. He doesn’t try to justify or excuse Benjamin. Instead, he appeals to Joseph’s (Yosef’s) compassion, recounting their father Jacob’s (Ya’akov’s) deep love for Benjamin and the devastating loss he would suffer if Benjamin did not return (Genesis 44:20–22).

    Judah says:

    “Now therefore, please let your servant remain instead of the boy as a servant to my lord, and let the boy go back with his brothers. For how can I go back to my father if the boy is not with me?” (Genesis 44:33–34, ESV)

    Judah makes several key points in his plea to Joseph:

    1. Their obedience in Egypt: Judah reminds Joseph that when they first came to Egypt, they came in good faith, simply to buy food for their families. They answered Joseph’s questions honestly and obeyed his instructions. Joseph, as the authority, had placed them in their predicament—not because of rebellion on their part, but because they submitted themselves to his authority.
    2. His heartfelt concern for Benjamin: Judah speaks specifically about his baby brother Benjamin’s relationship with their father, Jacob. He does not attempt to prove Benjamin’s innocence or argue that he was framed. Instead, he appeals to Joseph’s mercy. Judah explains that if Benjamin does not return home, Jacob will be crushed with grief. Benjamin, after all, was the only surviving son of Rachel in Jacob’s eyes, since Joseph was presumed dead. When Benjamin is accused, they do not allow him to be enslaved or executed, nor do they run away to save themselves. They are prepared to suffer together.
    3. Their love for their father: Judah’s love for his father is striking. He is willing to sacrifice his own life rather than cause Jacob further sorrow. This is a remarkable change from years earlier, when Judah and his brothers showed no such love or concern. Back then, they despised Joseph and were indifferent to the suffering they caused Jacob. Most of them wanted Joseph dead. Only Reuben spoke against killing him, while Judah suggested selling him into slavery. Now, however, the brothers stand together in adversity. When accused in Egypt, they refuse to abandon one another, even though their families are waiting back home.
    4. This is a radical transformation from the Judah who once suggested selling Joseph into slavery (Genesis 37:26–27). The Hebrew word for repentance, תשובה teshuvah, means “return” or “turning back.” Here, Judah demonstrates true teshuvah — not just feeling sorry, but changing his actions and priorities. He is willing to sacrifice himself for his brother and for his father’s sake.

      Once, Joseph’s brothers were callous and self-serving; now, they are men of loyalty and integrity. Their love for their father — and even for Benjamin — proves that they have matured. Judah’s own grief over the loss of his two sons may have given him a deeper understanding of the pain Jacob endured when Joseph was taken from him.

      Takeaway: Repentance is not just about regret; it’s about transformation. Judah’s willingness to stand in Benjamin’s place is a foreshadowing of the Messiah’s sacrificial love.

      The Brothers’ Growth: From Division to Unity

      (Genesis 44–45)

      Earlier in Genesis, Joseph’s brothers were divided—some wanted to kill him, others to save him, and Judah proposed selling him. Their actions were driven by jealousy and pain over their father’s favoritism (Genesis 37:3–4). But now, decades later, we see a united front. When Benjamin is accused, the brothers refuse to abandon him. They all return to Egypt together, standing as one.

      This unity is a sign of maturity. The Hebrew word אחדות achdut means “unity” or “oneness.” It’s a core value in Jewish thought—“Hinei mah tov u’mah na’im, shevet achim gam yachad” (“Behold, how good and pleasant it is for brothers to dwell together in unity!” – Psalm 133:1).

      Takeaway: Spiritual maturity is marked by unity and self-sacrifice. The brothers’ willingness to stand together, even at great personal cost, shows how God can transform hearts over time.

      Joseph’s Revelation: God’s Sovereign Plan and Forgiveness

      (Genesis 45:1–15)

      Judah’s selfless plea reaches its climax when Joseph reveals his identity. Imagine the brothers’ shock and shame in that moment. The viceroy of Egypt — the man they had feared and pleaded with — was none other than the brother they had betrayed. He knew everything. Nothing was hidden from him. He remembered their cruelty, their betrayal, his years of suffering.

      Yet Joseph does not respond with vengeance. Instead, he declares that although they meant evil against him, God used it for good — to save their lives and the lives of many others. Joseph’s maturity and faith shine through: he recognizes God’s hand in every circumstance, even in his own suffering.

      “And now do not be distressed or angry with yourselves because you sold me here, for God sent me before you to preserve life… So it was not you who sent me here, but God.”

      Genesis 45:5, 8

      Joseph recognizes that behind human choices—good and bad—God’s hand is at work. The Hebrew term השגחה פרטית hashgachah pratit means “divine providence.” Joseph sees his suffering and rise to power as part of God’s redemptive plan, not just a result of human actions.

      Humans have free will. Every day we make choices—whether to go left or right, whether to pursue one path or another. Joseph’s brothers used their free will to sell him into slavery, but God used that very choice to raise Joseph into a position where he could save them.

      Joseph forgives his brothers, echoing the biblical principle: “You shall not take vengeance or bear a grudge… but you shall love your neighbor as yourself” (Leviticus 19:18).

      This heart touching moment foreshadows how we will one day stand before Yeshua the Messiah in judgment. He knows everything—our words, our deeds, our hidden thoughts. Nothing will be concealed. The shame of that moment would be overwhelming if not for His mercy. Yet, just as Joseph offered forgiveness and salvation to his brothers, Yeshua offers forgiveness to us.

      Takeaway: God can use even our worst moments and free will choices for His greater purposes. Forgiveness and trust in God’s sovereignty are essential for healing and restoration.

      Caleb’s Faithfulness: Wholehearted Devotion Rewarded

      (Joshua 14:6–15)

      Fast forward to the days of Joshua. Caleb, now 85 years old, approaches Joshua to claim the inheritance promised to him by Moses. Caleb also had to stand before authority to receive what God had promised him. He did not appeal to Joshua’s emotions or attempt to persuade through human reasoning. Instead, he stood firmly on God’s word, recalling Moses’ promise, and on the testimony of his own faithfulness to the Lord and to Israel. Caleb’s confidence was not in himself, but in God’s faithfulness to fulfill His promises:

      “I wholly followed the LORD my God.”

      Joshua 14:8 ESV

      The Hebrew phrase is מלאתי אחרי יהוה אלהי maleti acharei Adonai Elohai — “I filled after the LORD my God,” meaning he followed God with his whole heart. Because of this, he is granted Hebron as his inheritance.

      Caleb’s heart was wholly devoted to the land of Hebron, and God rewarded him with it. Though he had no desire to wander in the wilderness for forty years after Israel rejected his faithful report, he endured it for God’s sake.

      Caleb’s story reminds us of the Greek word ὁλοκληρία holokleria, meaning “wholeness” or “completeness.” God honors those who serve Him with undivided hearts.

      Takeaway: Wholehearted devotion to God, even through long seasons of waiting and difficulty, leads to blessing and fulfillment of His promises.

      Yeshua on the Road to Emmaus: Suffering Before Glory

      (Luke 24:13–27)

      Now, let’s turn to the Brit Chadashah. After Yeshua’s resurrection, two disciples walk to Emmaus, discouraged and confused. Yeshua joins them, though they don’t recognize Him. He explains:

      “Was it not necessary that the Messiah should suffer these things and enter into His glory?”

      Luke 24:26 ESV

      The Greek word for “necessary” is δεῖ dei, meaning “it is necessary” or “it must be.” Yeshua shows that suffering was not an accident, but part of God’s redemptive plan foretold in the Torah and Prophets.

      Yeshua’s heart was fully devoted to doing the will of God. He did not desire to suffer and die, yet His love for the Father was greater than His own will. He could have refused, but instead He chose obedience — and was glorified.

      Yeshua interprets the Scriptures for them, revealing how the Messiah’s path always included suffering before glory — a pattern seen in Joseph and Caleb as well.

      Takeaway: God’s path to glory often leads through suffering. Yeshua’s journey fulfills the pattern established in the lives of Israel’s heroes.

      God’s Orchestration: Free Will and Divine Purpose

      (Genesis 50:20; Luke 24:25-27)

      A recurring theme in all these stories is the interplay between human free will and God’s sovereignty. Joseph’s brothers acted out of jealousy, Caleb chose faith over fear, and Yeshua publicly says that the people who crucified Him acted out of ignorance and malice. The Jewish leaders and Roman officials used their free will to condemn and crucify Him. Yet God used their choices to accomplish the greatest good—the glorification of Yeshua and the salvation of the world. Yet, as Joseph says:

      “As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good, to bring it about that many people should be kept alive.”

      Genesis 50:20, ESV

      As Yeshua explained to the disciples on the road to Emmaus:

      “And He said to them, “O foolish men and slow of heart to believe in all that the prophets have spoken! “Was it not necessary for the Christ to suffer these things and to enter into His glory?” Then beginning with Moses and with all the prophets, He explained to them the things concerning Himself in all the Scriptures.”

      Luke 24:25-27 NAS95

      Joseph, too, was raised to the highest position of authority in a foreign land—not by his own choice, but by God’s design. Joseph, Caleb and Yeshua, all had free will, yet they surrendered their own desires to follow God’s will. Whatever God required, they obeyed. Their paths demanded hard choices, and each of them suffered from the sinful decisions of others.

      The Hebrew term בחירה חופשית bechirah chofshit means “free choice.” God honors our choices, but He is never thwarted by them. He weaves even our failures into His tapestry of redemption.

      God weaves His purpose through both our obedience and even the sins of others against us, shaping us into the people He desires us to be.

      These events trace back generations, beginning with Jacob’s love for Rachel. Through flawed choices, family conflict, and even intermarriage with surrounding peoples, God still directed history toward His plan of salvation.

      Takeaway: God’s sovereignty and our free will are not in conflict. He masterfully orchestrates all things for His redemptive purposes.

      God Preserves Israel’s Identity

      (Genesis 34:1-2; Genesis 38:2; Genesis 46:34; Exodus 1:11-14; Deuteronomy 4:20)

      Jacob’s sons and their descendants faced a real danger of being absorbed into the surrounding Canaanite clans through intermarriage (Genesis 34:1–2; Genesis 38:2).

      To prevent this, God transplanted them into Egypt—where they were despised, shunned, and set apart (Genesis 46:34: “every shepherd is an abomination to the Egyptians”). The Egyptians wanted nothing to do with them, ensuring the family remained distinct (Exodus 1:11–12). God’s providence used Egypt’s hostility to ensure Israel’s distinct identity.

      In later generations, when the Egyptians enslaved the Israelites (Exodus 1:13–14), assimilation became even less likely. Oppression only reinforced their separation, making it unthinkable for Israel to be absorbed into Egyptian culture

      “But the LORD has taken you and brought you out of the iron furnace, from Egypt, to be a people for His own possession, as today.”

      Deuteronomy 4:20 NAS95

      The Hebrew word הַבְדָּלָה havdalah, means separation or distinction an is the term for the tradition of a special ceremony to close the weekly Shabbat (Sabbath). God separated Abraham and his immediate family from the pagans of Ur. He further refined Abraham’s line through Isaac and Jacob, in his divine act of setting Israel apart from surrounding nations.

      God’s Perfect Will Through Imperfect People

      Even Judah and his brothers were transformed. Once selfish and heartless, they became men of integrity — willing to sacrifice their own lives rather than break their father’s heart. Caleb, too, shows us that wholehearted devotion to God, even when it requires patience, endurance, and years of waiting, will never be in vain.

      From Judah’s selfless plea, to Joseph’s merciful forgiveness, to Caleb’s steadfast faith, and ultimately to Yeshua’s willing sacrifice in the face of the evil intent of those who thirsted for His death — we see the same truth: God works through human choices, even sinful ones, to bring about His perfect will.

      ...more
      View all episodesView all episodes
      Download on the App Store

      Hallel FellowshipBy Hallel Fellowship