Science on Track

Which Training Log is Accurate? GPS watches vs Athlete Reported Training


Listen Later

🎙️ Podcast Overview

Host: Evan Nelson, Associate Professor at theUniversity of Wisconsin
Guests:

    Dr. Micah Garcia, Assistant Professor at Thomas More University, expert in youth running
    Coach Charlie Burnham, Girls' Cross Country Coach at Burnsville High School, Burnsville, MN

🏃‍♂️ Topic: MeasuringTraining Load in High School Cross Country Runners

The episode explores how to best track training loads inhigh school runners, comparing GPS watches and electronictraining journals.

📊 Key Concepts

    External Load: Objective measures like distance and time.

    Internal Load: Subjective or physiological responses like perceived exertion or heart rate.

📄 Study Summary

Title: “Global Positioning System Watches and Electronic Journals: Are Training Load Measures Similar in High School Cross Country Runners?”
Published: 2022, International Journal of Sports Physiology and Performance
Authors: Dr. Micah Garcia & David Bazzett-Jones

🔍 Purpose:

To compare data from GPS watches and electronic journals toassess consistency in tracking training loads.

📈 Findings:

    GPS watches provided more consistent and complete data for external loads.

    Journals often had missing entries (about 1/3 of GPS-recorded runs were not journaled).

    When both sources were available, journal entries tended to overreport distance and time by ~10%.

    Internal load (perceived exertion vs. heart rate) showed poor agreement—heart rate data from wrist-based GPS watches was often inaccurate.

🧠 Insights from Dr. Garcia

    GPS watches are more reliable for external load tracking.

    Subjective perceived exertion may be more accurate than wrist-based heart rate for internal load.

    Coaches should choose tools based on their goals and available resources.

🏫 Coaching Perspectivefrom Coach Burnham

    Prioritizes external load (time and distance), especially time-based training for inclusivity.

    Uses a Google spreadsheet for summer training logs; less structured during the season.

    Emphasizes fun, consistency, and long-term love for the sport over strict data tracking.

    Notes challenges with technology access, motivation, and accuracy among high school athletes.

🧩 Practical Takeaways

    GPS watches are effective for capturing external load but may not reflect perceived effort.

    Self-reported intensity is valuable but requires routine and motivation.

    Coaching context matters: team size, athlete experience, and program goals influence the best tracking method.

Hungria Hip Hop - Meu Carona (Wilde BeatsRemix) By Dj WildeBeats is licensed under a Creative Commons License.


...more
View all episodesView all episodes
Download on the App Store

Science on TrackBy Velocity Project

  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5
  • 5

5

4 ratings


More shows like Science on Track

View all
Just Fly Performance Podcast by Joel Smith, Just-Fly-Sports.com

Just Fly Performance Podcast

371 Listeners

The Gill Athletics Track and Field Connections Podcast by Gill Athletics

The Gill Athletics Track and Field Connections Podcast

72 Listeners

The On Track & Field Podcast! by On Track & Field, Inc

The On Track & Field Podcast!

35 Listeners