The Idol Talk Podcast is back!

In this week’s episode, hosts Peyton and Jacob discuss their selections for a New Era All-Stars cast. After a brief update on their personal lives, including Peyton’s recent move from Florida to Oklahoma City, they dive deep into the ‘budget era’ of Survivor seasons 41 through 46.

They rank their favorite seasons based on the cast and explore which players they believe deserve a spot in an All-Stars season. They create three dream tribes, debating the merits and dynamics of each player, including notable contestants like Jesse, Ricard, Jonathan, Emily, Maria, and Dee. They also discuss the potential for iconic returnee seasons such as New Era All-Stars, New Era Second Chances, and Heroes vs. Villains 2. The episode is the first of a three-part series that will continue to explore each of these ideas.

-

00:00 Intro

01:44 Ranking the Best New Era Casts

09:44 Speculating Survivor Season 50

12:05 Dream Casting New Era All-Stars

45:58 Finalizing the Tribes

54:05 Wrapping Up and Future Parts

-

Final Tribes:

Tribe Jesse

Tribe Ricard

Tribe Jonathan

-

Music:

Consequence - Wonders⁠ by ⁠Kevin MacLeod⁠ is licensed under a ⁠Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 license.