Sign up to save your podcasts
Or
Share Why Both Political Parties Have Their Heads Up Their Asses About Immigration
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Share to email
Share to Facebook
Share to X
Or
Why Both Political Parties Have Their Heads Up Their Asses About Immigration
Send us a text
The immigration crisis at our southern border has become one of America's most divisive political battlegrounds—but what if both sides are missing the obvious solution? Drawing from personal experience living in Southern Arizona and working alongside immigrant communities, I break down why current approaches from both Democrats and Republicans are fundamentally flawed.
When riots break out in Los Angeles with protesters waving Mexican flags and destroying property, it's easy to understand the call for stronger enforcement. Yet the Republican fantasy of "rounding up" 20 million undocumented immigrants ignores basic reality—even the most oppressive regimes in history couldn't accomplish such a feat. Meanwhile, Democrats who dismiss legitimate security concerns or pretend illegal immigration has no negative consequences are equally disconnected from reality.
The solution? A pragmatic "orange card" program that brings undocumented immigrants who arrived before a specific date into the legal system—allowing them to work, pay taxes, and live openly—but without a path to citizenship or voting rights. This addresses Republican concerns about changing voting demographics while recognizing the demographic reality that America's aging population needs more workers to support our welfare state.
For future immigration, I propose unlimited green cards for those who meet three simple criteria: financial self-sufficiency, no criminal record, and good health. This recognizes that Latino immigrants, contrary to Republican fears, often align with conservative values due to their predominantly Catholic, pro-life beliefs.
The missing piece in this puzzle is ending the failed War on Drugs, which has cost over a trillion dollars without stopping the flow of narcotics (even into our prisons). By redirecting those resources toward catching actual violent criminals at the border, we could create a system that works for everyone.
Our immigration debate doesn't need more shouting—it needs adults willing to acknowledge reality and find practical trade-offs. Listen in as I break down why both parties need to pull their heads out of their collective posteriors and embrace solutions that actually work.
Support the show
View all episodes
By HerbySend us a text
The immigration crisis at our southern border has become one of America's most divisive political battlegrounds—but what if both sides are missing the obvious solution? Drawing from personal experience living in Southern Arizona and working alongside immigrant communities, I break down why current approaches from both Democrats and Republicans are fundamentally flawed.
When riots break out in Los Angeles with protesters waving Mexican flags and destroying property, it's easy to understand the call for stronger enforcement. Yet the Republican fantasy of "rounding up" 20 million undocumented immigrants ignores basic reality—even the most oppressive regimes in history couldn't accomplish such a feat. Meanwhile, Democrats who dismiss legitimate security concerns or pretend illegal immigration has no negative consequences are equally disconnected from reality.
The solution? A pragmatic "orange card" program that brings undocumented immigrants who arrived before a specific date into the legal system—allowing them to work, pay taxes, and live openly—but without a path to citizenship or voting rights. This addresses Republican concerns about changing voting demographics while recognizing the demographic reality that America's aging population needs more workers to support our welfare state.
For future immigration, I propose unlimited green cards for those who meet three simple criteria: financial self-sufficiency, no criminal record, and good health. This recognizes that Latino immigrants, contrary to Republican fears, often align with conservative values due to their predominantly Catholic, pro-life beliefs.
The missing piece in this puzzle is ending the failed War on Drugs, which has cost over a trillion dollars without stopping the flow of narcotics (even into our prisons). By redirecting those resources toward catching actual violent criminals at the border, we could create a system that works for everyone.
Our immigration debate doesn't need more shouting—it needs adults willing to acknowledge reality and find practical trade-offs. Listen in as I break down why both parties need to pull their heads out of their collective posteriors and embrace solutions that actually work.
Support the show