Values Investors Podcast | Socially Responsible Investing, ESG, Ethical, Impact, Sustainable Investments

Why Expats Should Keep Their Investments in the US


Listen Later

Protect Your Wealth While Living Abroad
✅ Lower Costs | ✅ Better Investments | ✅ Easier Taxes
💡 Learn why keeping your U.S. accounts (and address!) is the smartest move for expats.

🌍 Why Americans Living in Mexico, Spain, France, or Italy Should Keep Their Investments in the US — and Keep a U.S. Address

📅 Book a Free Consultation

Living abroad comes with incredible benefits — lifestyle, culture, food, and cost of living — but it also brings serious financial planning challenges. U.S. citizens living in places like Mexico, Spain, France, or Italy must carefully manage their investments, taxes, and residency to avoid losing access to the U.S. financial system or triggering unintended tax consequences abroad.

This guide covers everything you need to know to make smart, compliant decisions — and to keep your financial life secure, wherever you live.

✅ Why Keep Your Investment Accounts in the U.S.?

Keeping your brokerage, retirement, and investment accounts in the U.S. is usually the best choice for Americans abroad. Here’s why:

  1. Lower Costs
    • U.S. ETFs and index funds have some of the lowest expense ratios in the world (as low as 0.03%)
    • Foreign funds (especially in Europe and Mexico) often charge 1%–2% or more annually
    • U.S. brokers rarely charge custody or annual maintenance fees
      1. Better Investment Choices
        • Access to thousands of mutual funds, ETFs, and stocks
        • U.S. platforms offer robust options in ESG, tech, emerging markets, fixed income, and more
        • Foreign brokers often limit access or block U.S.-domiciled investments
          1. Simpler Tax Reporting
            • U.S.-based investments are not subject to PFIC rules
            • Investing in foreign funds (like UCITS ETFs in Europe) means:
              • Filing IRS Form 8621
              • Possible punitive tax treatment
              • High reporting burdens for each fund annually
                1. Stronger Protection
                  • U.S. brokers are regulated by SEC and FINRA
                  • Investor funds are insured up to $500,000 by SIPC
                  • Transparent disclosures and support in English
                    1. Better Retirement Integration
                      • U.S. accounts are the only place to hold:
                        • Traditional IRAs
                        • Roth IRAs
                        • 401(k)s, SEP IRAs, and inherited IRAs
                        • 🏠 Why You Need a U.S. Address

                          To keep a U.S. brokerage or retirement account open and fully functional, you typically must have a U.S. residential address on file.

                          Why It Matters
                          What Happens Without a U.S. Address
                          Regulatory compliance
                          Brokers may freeze or restrict trading
                          U.S. mutual funds & ETFs
                          Blocked if you’re flagged as an EU resident (PRIIPs regulation)
                          Retirement accounts
                          May not allow new contributions or rollovers
                          Account updates or re-verification
                          May fail without a valid U.S. residential address
                          📬 How to Maintain a U.S. Address (Even While Living Abroad)

                          ✅ Best Options:

                          1. Use a trusted friend or family member’s residential address
                            • Must be a real home (not a PO box or commercial mail center)
                            • Most reliable and widely accepted
                            • Rent or own property in the U.S.
                              • Can be small or shared; gives you legal “domicile”
                              • Lets you keep a U.S. driver’s license and voter registration
                              • ⚠️ Risky Options:

                                • Virtual mailboxes (e.g., iPostal1, Traveling Mailbox)
                                  • These provide real street addresses, but most brokers flag them as CMRA (Commercial Mail Receiving Agency) and may reject them.
                                  • PO Boxes and UPS Store mailboxes
                                    • Explicitly rejected by financial institutions
                                    • 🧾 Do You Still Have to File Taxes in the U.S. and Abroad?

                                      Yes. As a U.S. citizen:

                                      • You must file a U.S. tax return every year, no matter where you live
                                      • You must also report worldwide income, including:
                                        • Investment dividends and capital gains
                                        • Roth IRA withdrawals
                                        • Foreign-earned income (even if it’s excluded under FEIE)
                                        • If you’re also a tax resident abroad, you will likely have to file two tax returns: one in the U.S., and one in your country of residence.

                                          Country
                                          When You’re Considered a Tax Resident
                                          🇲🇽 Mexico
                                          183+ days or “center of vital interests”
                                          🇫🇷 France
                                          183+ days or habitual residence
                                          🇪🇸 Spain
                                          183+ days or economic interest
                                          🇮🇹 Italy
                                          183+ days or habitual residence or registered address
                                          ⚖️ What About Enforcement? Will They Know?

                                          🇲🇽 Mexico

                                          • Enforcement is still relatively light for personal investment income
                                          • Many expats do not file Mexican returns, especially if income is low or passive
                                          • That said, Mexico participates in FATCA, and enforcement is gradually increasing
                                          • 🇪🇸🇫🇷🇮🇹 Europe

                                            • Enforcement is much stricter
                                            • These countries participate in:
                                              • FATCA (U.S. reporting)
                                              • CRS (Common Reporting Standard for global tax transparency)
                                              • Foreign financial institutions and tax authorities receive U.S. account data
                                              • Non-disclosure of Roth IRA withdrawals or large foreign balances can trigger penalties or audits
                                              • 💸 Are Roth IRA Withdrawals Tax-Free Abroad?

                                                In the U.S., qualified Roth IRA withdrawals are tax-free. But that’s not how other countries see it.

                                                🌍 Abroad:

                                                • Mexico, Spain, France, and Italy do NOT recognize Roth IRAs as tax-exempt
                                                • Roth distributions are often treated as ordinary income
                                                • You are legally required to report Roth withdrawals in your country of residence
                                                • Country
                                                  Roth IRA Withdrawal Taxed?
                                                  🇺🇸 U.S.
                                                  ❌ No (if qualified)
                                                  🇲🇽 Mexico
                                                  ✅ Yes
                                                  🇪🇸 Spain
                                                  ✅ Yes
                                                  🇫🇷 France
                                                  ✅ Yes
                                                  🇮🇹 Italy
                                                  ✅ Yes

                                                  Even if enforcement is low, you’re legally responsible for reporting Roth income abroad.

                                                  💰 Do You Have to Worry About Wealth Taxes?

                                                  Yes — in certain countries, your worldwide assets (including U.S. accounts) may be subject to annual wealth tax.

                                                  Country
                                                  Wealth Tax Notes
                                                  🇲🇽 Mexico
                                                  ❌ No wealth tax
                                                  🇪🇸 Spain
                                                  ✅ Yes, varies by region. Madrid has 100% exemption. Catalonia and Valencia impose higher rates
                                                  🇫🇷 France
                                                  ✅ Yes, but only on real estate over €1.3 million
                                                  🇨🇭 Switzerland
                                                  ✅ Yes, varies by canton
                                                  🇮🇹 Italy
                                                  ✅ Yes, for foreign financial assets (IVAFE tax)

                                                  📌 If you’re in a country with a wealth tax, you’ll likely need to declare your U.S. brokerage balances, including IRAs.

                                                  🪪 Which U.S. State Should You “Live In” for Financial Purposes?

                                                  Choosing a tax-friendly state for your legal address can reduce complexity and risk.

                                                  ✅ Best States with No State Income Tax:

                                                  • Texas
                                                  • Florida
                                                  • Nevada
                                                  • Wyoming
                                                  • Washington
                                                  • South Dakota
                                                  • Alaska
                                                  • Tennessee (taxes interest/dividends only)
                                                  • New Hampshire (taxes interest/dividends only)
                                                  • 📌 Texas and Florida are especially popular among expats due to:

                                                    • No state income tax
                                                    • Friendly DMV rules
                                                    • Reciprocity for driver’s license exchange in France
                                                    • 🚗 Driver’s License Reciprocity in Europe

                                                      Maintaining a U.S. driver’s license from the right state can save you a lot of time and money.

                                                      🇫🇷 France

                                                      • Allows license exchange without testing from these states:
                                                        • Texas
                                                        • Florida
                                                        • Pennsylvania
                                                        • New Hampshire
                                                        • And others
                                                        • 🇲🇽 Mexico

                                                          • Most states accept U.S. licenses to obtain a local one; no formal reciprocity needed
                                                          • 🇪🇸 Spain, 🇮🇹 Italy

                                                            • No reciprocity: you’ll have to retake both written and driving exams
                                                            • 💳 What About U.S. Credit Cards?

                                                              Keeping U.S. credit cards is another strong reason to maintain a U.S. address.

                                                              Benefits:

                                                              • No foreign transaction fees (with the right card)
                                                              • Better rewards: cashback, travel miles, hotel perks
                                                              • Purchase protection and fraud support
                                                              • Access to services like TSA PreCheck, Global Entry, and U.S. travel insurance
                                                              • 🧾 Most credit cards require a U.S. billing address, and many issuers check that it’s a residential address — not a commercial one.

                                                                🧠 Final Takeaways
                                                                Topic
                                                                Recommendation
                                                                Investment accounts
                                                                ✅ Keep them in the U.S.
                                                                Address requirement
                                                                ✅ Use a real U.S. residential address
                                                                Roth IRA distributions
                                                                ✅ Report abroad; taxable outside U.S.
                                                                Filing taxes
                                                                ✅ Yes, both in the U.S. and locally
                                                                Tax enforcement
                                                                ⚠️ Light in Mexico, strict in Europe
                                                                Wealth tax
                                                                ⚠️ Depends on country/region
                                                                Best states
                                                                ✅ TX or FL (no tax, license reciprocity)
                                                                Credit cards
                                                                ✅ Maintain U.S. address for access
                                                                Driver’s license
                                                                ✅ Consider states with reciprocity (TX, FL)
                                                                📍 About AIO Financial

                                                                AIO Financial is a fee-only fiduciary firm that specializes in working with U.S. expats in Mexico and Europe. We don’t sell products or earn commissions — just experienced, independent guidance tailored to your cross-border life.

                                                                We help you:

                                                                • Keep U.S. accounts open legally
                                                                • Avoid PFICs and reporting traps
                                                                • Coordinate Roth IRA distributions abroad
                                                                • Plan for wealth taxes and foreign filing
                                                                • Anchor your financial life in the best U.S. state
                                                                • 📅 Book your free consultation now

                                                                  Let’s make your financial life abroad simpler, safer, and more strategic.

                                                                  Transcript of podcast/video:

                                                                  Americans abroad

                                                                  should keep their investments in the US
                                                                  so expats
                                                                  I’m gonna talk about cross border financial planning
                                                                  expats in Mexico France
                                                                  Spain Italy
                                                                  Europe should keep their investments in the US
                                                                  we’re gonna talk about why
                                                                  the benefits of keeping investments in the US
                                                                  lower investment fees exchange traded funds
                                                                  have expense ratios as low as point o 3%
                                                                  sometimes even lower
                                                                  there’s thousands of investment options
                                                                  thousands of exchange traded funds
                                                                  mutual funds stocks
                                                                  the expense ratios
                                                                  in some of these European funds are 1 to 2%
                                                                  you’re just losing a lot of investment power
                                                                  the investment options are a lot more limited
                                                                  they’re trying to protect the investors
                                                                  but they’re limiting you quite a bit
                                                                  you get to avoid this PFIC
                                                                  European taxation
                                                                  you have some regulatory Protection
                                                                  a lot of transparency Protection like the SEC
                                                                  FINRA CIPIC and you have access to IRAs
                                                                  Roth
                                                                  401ks in the US you don’t have that access overseas
                                                                  why do you need a US address
                                                                  you need an address
                                                                  if you want to keep a US brokerage account
                                                                  an account that holds these mutual funds
                                                                  stocks exchange traded funds
                                                                  and have full access
                                                                  to all those different investment options
                                                                  so if you want to trade everything you
                                                                  you want to be able to trade
                                                                  you need a US address it’s required for IRA
                                                                  401k contributions rollovers
                                                                  and to avoid being restricted by the EU
                                                                  PRIIP regulations
                                                                  how do you keep a US address if you’re living abroad
                                                                  well you can use family member
                                                                  trusted friends residential address
                                                                  you can rent or maintain property in the US
                                                                  these Po boxes
                                                                  commercial mail mailboxes are not allowed
                                                                  virtual mailboxes sometimes work
                                                                  we have clients that use these virtual mailboxes
                                                                  and we’ve seen them work they don’t always work
                                                                  sometimes Schwab or Vanguard will flag them
                                                                  and they’ll say hey
                                                                  this person is not here we need a physical address
                                                                  and they’ll flag it
                                                                  and they have to come up with a physical address
                                                                  you could try it it may not work
                                                                  so the best option is get a physical address
                                                                  somewhere where you have a friend
                                                                  family member
                                                                  somewhere where there’s a physical mailbox
                                                                  tax filing and enforcement
                                                                  so US citizens must file annually with the IRS
                                                                  US taxes on worldwide income
                                                                  if you have interest dividends
                                                                  Social Security income
                                                                  pensions all that is gonna get taxed
                                                                  you’re gonna file a US tax return
                                                                  now you may be in a country
                                                                  where you’re not getting double taxed
                                                                  but you’re filing a US US return
                                                                  and if you’re paying taxes in Mexico
                                                                  you don’t get double tax you don’t have to pay it twice
                                                                  but you’re filing a return
                                                                  most times
                                                                  you’re also filing in your country of residence
                                                                  so if you’re living in Mexico
                                                                  if you’re living in Spain
                                                                  you’re gonna file a Spanish return
                                                                  or an Italian return or a French return as well Mexico
                                                                  their enforcement is like many ex pats
                                                                  many Americans living in Mexico do not file
                                                                  Mexican returns but enforcement is growing
                                                                  so in five years that may change
                                                                  currently there’s not a ton of enforcement but again
                                                                  that could be a different situation however
                                                                  in Spain France
                                                                  Italy in Europe
                                                                  you are gonna be filing there Roth IRA distributions
                                                                  this is something to be aware of and plan accordingly
                                                                  it is tax free to distribute from your Roth IRA if
                                                                  if it’s qualified
                                                                  if you have your five years
                                                                  if you’re of age fifty nine and a/2
                                                                  but it in the US
                                                                  you can take these distributions and if it qualifies
                                                                  it’s tax free
                                                                  abroad usually it’s a taxable distribution
                                                                  it’ll get taxed just like an IRA
                                                                  even though you already paid taxes on the money
                                                                  you put into it
                                                                  you pay taxes again when you pull it out
                                                                  so most countries are not recognizing it
                                                                  that it’s a Roth
                                                                  they’re just seeing it as an IRA and taxing on
                                                                  on it when comes out so plan accordingly
                                                                  pull out what you can before you go abroad
                                                                  if you’re permanently going going abroad
                                                                  you have to report those withdrawals
                                                                  if you are a resident of that new country
                                                                  wealth taxes be aware of wealth taxes
                                                                  Spain has wealth taxes
                                                                  Italy has wealth taxes they’re not the same everywhere
                                                                  there’s exemptions for real estate
                                                                  Spain has wealth taxes that’s that are different higher
                                                                  Madrid has an exemption under Lucia
                                                                  it’s very small um I I almost zero um
                                                                  they’re they’re not but just be aware of them
                                                                  and maybe your wealth is under it
                                                                  and you don’t pay anything
                                                                  um but just where that could be an issue uh
                                                                  franchise real estate tax so just on real estate
                                                                  when you’re picking a state
                                                                  so if you’re getting your US location
                                                                  if you have an option
                                                                  pick a state with no income tax if you have an option
                                                                  now if your family or friends are in Arizona great
                                                                  that’s what you’re stuck with um
                                                                  but if if you have a choice between Texas
                                                                  Florida or New York and California
                                                                  well pick one with the lower state tax um
                                                                  some states offer license reciprocal agreements
                                                                  so if you have a driver’s license in Texas
                                                                  and you’re moving to France
                                                                  well they’ll respect that
                                                                  and it’ll make it
                                                                  so much easier to get a driver’s license
                                                                  in France they’ll respect your Texas driver’s license
                                                                  but they won’t
                                                                  won’t respect your driver’s license so it
                                                                  it’s worth doing a little research on what states
                                                                  have a reciprocal agreement with the country
                                                                  you’re moving to if
                                                                  if there is a
                                                                  in Mexico there aren’t any reciprocal agreements
                                                                  but
                                                                  it’s not that hard to get a driver’s license in Mexico
                                                                  um but be aware of taxes yeah
                                                                  if you have a choice
                                                                  then you’re just gonna be in the state that you’re in
                                                                  other reasons to keep a US address
                                                                  so if you want credit cards uh
                                                                  less fees rewards
                                                                  there could be that you want a US credit card
                                                                  you want those airport lounges great
                                                                  you will need a US address to have those
                                                                  US credit cards if you want US bank
                                                                  then you’re gonna need that receiving Social Security
                                                                  Medicare notices
                                                                  they’re gonna want a US address US phone number
                                                                  I mean sometimes you could around that mail access
                                                                  those could be reasons voter registration for sure
                                                                  Global Entry travel documents
                                                                  all those are nice reasons
                                                                  or perks or pluses to having a US address
                                                                  so in summary
                                                                  it is nice to have US investment accounts
                                                                  it’ll save you expenses
                                                                  it’ll save you taxes to have those to have full access
                                                                  there are workarounds
                                                                  you know you can swab International
                                                                  it’s more limited uh but it’s best
                                                                  you have most access if you have a US address
                                                                  uh be careful with that’s an issue
                                                                  if you are living abroad
                                                                  be if you choice be careful or not be careful
                                                                  but be selective on the state you pick be strategic um
                                                                  if you’re moving to Europe
                                                                  you know avoid some foreign mutual funds
                                                                  use US funds stay compliant with US and tax laws
                                                                  you don’t want things
                                                                  you don’t want these issues to bite you later
                                                                  that’s it we have a blog that has more information
                                                                  spells us out in more detail
                                                                  I’m Bill Holiday AIO Financial
                                                                  let me know if you have any questions more detail
                                                                  this is really a brief overview
                                                                  we are we only financial planning advisors
                                                                  we deal with sustainable
                                                                  responsible impact invest investing
                                                                  we also with cross border financial
                                                                  planning
                                                                  mostly with Americans living in Mexico and Europe
                                                                  primarily in Spain France
                                                                  Italy um let me know do you have any questions
                                                                  be glad to help we offer a free consultation
                                                                  lots of information on our website a I 0 financial.com
                                                                  we have some free tools we have free um apps
                                                                  a budget app
                                                                  retirement planning app we have some ebooks
                                                                  little courses and videos
                                                                  follow us leave a comment
                                                                  and let me know if you have any questions
                                                                  I really appreciate it thanks a lot bye

                                                                  The post Why Expats Should Keep Their Investments in the US appeared first on AIO Financial - Fee Only Financial Advisors.

                                                                  ...more
                                                                  View all episodesView all episodes
                                                                  Download on the App Store

                                                                  Values Investors Podcast | Socially Responsible Investing, ESG, Ethical, Impact, Sustainable InvestmentsBy Bill Holliday, CFP