What happens when a mountain lion advocate, a sheep producer, and a houndsman sit down to talk about the future of mountain lions in Utah?
In this episode of The Wildlife Wire, Samantha Miller is joined by three people whose relationships with mountain lions could hardly look more different: Denise of Utah Mountain Lion Conservation, southern Utah sheep producer and houndsman Andy Rice, and lifelong hunter and houndsman Aaron Johnson.
Despite coming from different backgrounds, they have found substantial common ground: Utah needs to return to sustainable, science-based mountain lion management.
The conversation explores how Utah’s approach to mountain lions has changed in recent years, including the removal of harvest limits, year-round hunting and concerns about a state effort to lethally remove lions in an attempt to increase deer numbers.
Andy offers a particularly compelling perspective from the livestock community. After years of raising sheep in lion country, he says his experience has shown that a stable population of mature, territorial mountain lions can actually reduce livestock losses. Removing established cats can create instability as younger, transient lions move into newly vacant territories.
Aaron discusses what houndsmen are seeing on the ground, including concerns about declining age classes, fewer mature lions and the long-term consequences of treating predator removal as a primary strategy for increasing deer populations.
The group also tackles a question that often gets lost in polarized wildlife debates: What if people who value mountain lions for very different reasons worked together on the things they agree on?
They discuss targeted responses to livestock depredation, sustainable harvest limits, the role of hunters and houndsmen in conservation, and why maintaining stable mountain lion populations can benefit livestock producers, hunters, wildlife watchers—and the lions themselves.
It is a conversation about predators, hunting, agriculture and conservation, but also about something increasingly rare in wildlife politics: finding common ground.
How mountain lion management has changed in UtahWhat houndsmen are seeing in Utah’s lion populationsWhy killing more lions does not produce more deerHow stable lion populations can reduce livestock conflictThe value of mature, territorial mountain lionsTargeting individual depredating animals instead of broadly reducing populationsFinding common ground among hunters, ranchers and wildlife advocatesBuilding a coalition for sustainable, science-based mountain lion management