Your team belongs at the table, but do they feel like they matter?
On this episode of Win Win Leadership, Dr. Karen McDaniel sits down with John R. Miles, a U.S. Naval Academy graduate, 13-year naval officer, four-time Fortune 50 executive, and host of the Passion Struck podcast, where he has interviewed more than 700 leaders. John's new book, The Mattering Effect, explains why loneliness, disengagement, and burnout are not separate problems but symptoms of one root cause: people no longer feeling that they matter.
John shares his story, from a childhood traumatic brain injury and a teacher who told him he'd never amount to anything, to "disappearing" inside the high-performing systems he led. He explains the difference between belonging and mattering, outlines the six conditions of mattering (meaning, autonomy, trust, time, energy, and reciprocity), and tells how he turned the most disengaged team in a 350,000-person company into a model for the whole organization by becoming a "gardener leader."
You'll also hear why engagement surveys miss the real story, how to spot a trust problem by finding where your organization is quietest, what "return on energy" means for frontline supervisors, and why AI makes the human side of leadership more important, not less.
If you lead people, this conversation will change how you think about performance.
π Get The Mattering Effect: matteringeffect.com
ποΈ Learn more about John: johnrmiles.com
π Selected for the Next Big Idea Club's October must-read list
Subscribe to Win Win Leadership for more conversations on authentic, collaborative leadership where everyone can rise.
What You'll Learn
- The critical difference between belonging and mattering, and why capable leaders often miss it
- Why engagement surveys can give a false picture of how employees really feel
- The six conditions of mattering: meaning, autonomy, trust, time, energy, and reciprocity
- Why you must restore mattering in yourself before you can create it for others
- How to move from servant leader to gardener leader, and give autonomy within clear boundaries
- How to diagnose a trust problem ("people speak with their feet")
- Why reciprocity is the "shared seesaw" and how the "mattering tax" shows up as burnout and disengagement
- How to measure return on energy and protect your frontline supervisors
- The Deliberate Action Process: analyze, prioritize, ignite, execute, measure, renew
- Why AI makes the human dividend the new competitive advantage
- The one thing to do tomorrow so your team feels they matter
Timestamps00:00 β Welcome & introducing John R. Miles
01:00 β A childhood brain injury and the speech therapist who made him matter
04:00 β The teacher who said he'd never amount to anything
06:00 β Disappearing inside the systems he led
07:30 β Belonging vs. mattering
08:30 β Why engagement surveys miss the real story
10:00 β "Erasure by design": the root cause behind loneliness and burnout
12:00 β Mattering isn't instead of performance; it drives it
13:30 β The true cost of the mattering gap
15:30 β The six conditions of mattering
18:30 β Why mattering starts with yourself
20:00 β The condition leaders get wrong most: autonomy
21:00 β Lowe's: leading the most disengaged team in a 350,000-person company
24:00 β From servant leader to gardener leader
26:30 β Failure as a teaching moment ("the glass is refillable")
28:00 β Rebuilding trust: people speak with their feet
31:00 β Reciprocity and the shared seesaw
33:00 β Return on energy: protecting frontline supervisors
35:00 β Building a culture of significance: Lowe's vs. Dell
38:00 β The Deliberate Action Process
40:00 β Why leaders struggle with execution: your "because" before your "why"
41:30 β Mattering in negotiations and tough conversations
43:30 β AI and the mattering dividend
45:00 β Authenticity and the pyramid of mattering
46:00 β The one thing leaders should do tomorrow
47:00 β Where to find John and The Mattering Effect
48:00 β Final thoughts: creating the conditions to flourish