Yeah, this is late. And a bit of a long one. Sorry/not sorry! We were real enthusiastic about it! Talking points include: new tattoos! A book and movie review! Pinnacle of Supernatural = so many thoughts and feelings. Jensen plays a good murderer! Lies lies and more lies. SO much tampering of evidence in an open case!!! The shapeshifter shedding his skin is yucky, and so is his heart. Younger sibling annoyances! Wait, why don't the Winchester boys wear holsters?? The minutia in this episode that build into seasons' worth of backstory!!! Despite the face, the vibe is ick. Paley Festival 2006 shoutout. "HEY." And so much more!

Check us out on Tik Tok @winchester.fam.reunion and on Insta @winchesterfamreunion!

Music by ⁠⁠nickpanek

Okay, so maybe this episode of Supernatural didn't give us the spooks as much as it gave us the icks. That still works as we creep closer to the heart of Spooky Season, right?

Discussion points include: pre-Halloween festivities, do kids even play Bloody Mary anymore??, wait, do kids even have sleepovers anymore??!, THANKS DAD, Dean can't flirt his way through everything :(, walking into a wake in jeans, magic wi-fi and photo printers, car heart to hearts and secrets, the start of loooore!, Ring-style crawling = no thanks!, speculation about Dean's eyes crying blood, men would rather hunt than go to therapy, and much more!

Check us out on Tik Tok @winchester.fam.reunion and on Insta @winchesterfamreunion!

Music by ⁠nickpanek

Discussing Supernatural episode 4, Phantom Traveler, should obviously begin with a very confused discussion on Gilmore Girls. Sorry!

Discussion also includes Chrissy's (much like Dean) mega distaste of airports and flying, how much the lore around demons has changed since this episode so long ago, probably one too many mentions of 9/11, the Ackles Ass Equation, the disappearing EMF meter, microscopic sulfur, demons vs devils, the incredible journey of Dean's fear of flying, and much much more.

Check us out on Tik Tok @winchester.fam.reunion and on Insta @winchesterfamreunion!

Music by ⁠⁠nickpanek

Dead in the Water! Hey, this episode is kinda a bummer, huh. Chrissy and Sarah discuss Sam's (earned) petulance (x 2), not taking life lessons from Dean Winchester, LITTLE GHOST BOY!!, the wonderful world of early Supernatural CGI, baths = bad, Andrea's very bad no good week, and much more.

Music by ⁠nickpanek

Wendigo! Chrissy and Sarah discuss Supernatural's second episode and discuss recaps and slo-mo, bad (?) gore, nasty piss boys, the (earned) petulance of Sam, Dean's incredibly high charisma stats, ponderings of why so much circus music?, THE Iconic Line, a hurted Dean, and more!

Music by ⁠nickpanek

Where else to start but at the beginning? We introduce ourselves, recap our fandom history, and of course, take an in depth look into Supernatural episode 1, Pilot.

Music by nickpanek