JoBeth gets to the bottom of what happened to her missing co-host, Donna with special guest, Donna!

JoBeth goes through all the possible suspects and theories to try and solve what happened to her co-host Donna, who has gone missing.

Guests: John Lutz, Maya Rudolph

Jobeth and Donna learn all about the world of Tik Tok when an influencer is murdered. The roommate and musical influencer duo Shimmer Town comes on the show to sing all the gory details. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, Rashawn Scott, Jiavani. Music by Zach Marsh.

Guests: Rashawn Scott, Jiavani, and Zach Marsh

This week Donna takes a stab at researching the crime, bringing on her psychic friend Rose to help find out what really happened. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, and Maya Rudolph.

Guests: Maya Rudolph

Jobeth and Donna look into a murder at an all-female yoga retreat, excited to finally have discovered a murder committed by a woman (they hope) . Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, Paula Pell, and Janine Brito.

Guests: Paula Pell, Janine Brit

Jobeth and Donna talk to an HR manager in major damage-control after an office lunch is poisoned. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, and James Anderson.

Guests: James Anderson

Jobeth and Donna tell the story of a serial killer who liked to give his victims “one perfect last day” before killing them. His last almost victim is Jobeth’s brother and Liz’s ex-boyfriend, Ray. And no, Donna is still not over him. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, and John Lutz.

Guests: John Lutz

Jobeth and Donna interview a charming killer in prison, who claims innocence in the death of his three wives, all of whom were killed in identical boating accidents. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, and Lisa Gilroy.

Guests: Lisa Gilroy

Jobeth and Donna dive into the archive and immerse themselves in a 1970s whodunnit: a high school track star is murdered by his best friend, who is “possessed” by a demon they meet via a Ouija board. Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, Craig Cackowski, and Will Forte.

Guests: Will Forte and Craig Cackowski

Jobeth and Donna investigate a couple who raised listener suspicion on the therapy podcast Say More Dr? Sheila when it was revealed that they met on a cruise ship where the wife, still on her honeymoon, became a widow under mysterious circumstances. Dr? Sheila weighs in, as does a cruise ship comedian and eyewitness.

 Starring Emily Spivey, Liz Cackowski, Amy Poehler, and Jason Schwartzman.

Guests: Amy Poehler, Jason Schwartzman